Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 2, 2020 21:59:03 GMT
Yeah what have we done? We sacked one of the worst managers in the history of our club? With an atrocious record? Who assembled one of the most unbalanced, inexperienced, inept squads I've seen as a gashead. How terrible. What did we do letting him sign 4 left backs? What did we do letting him sell our best striker, release more or less all the rest, and only sign a kid, a player who hasn't played a league game before, and a striker who's renowned for not being a goalscorer and leaving us exposed to injury? What did we do letting him release Tony Craig and letting him replace him with Max Ehmer and Jack Baldwin What did we do letting him force out Abu Ogogo who wore his heart on his sleeve and bled blue blood for us? and Replacing him with Grant who can't be assed to go for a second ball and run back after that second ball? What did we do? Just because he could get the best out of his sh** squad over 3 fixtures doesn't make him worthy of the managers position or mean the new manager aint any good. Spot on. Only one person responsible for this and he was rightly shown the door. How on earth people can blame Tisdale after less than two weeks in the job is beyond me. Hopefully PT can sort us out sufficiently to avoid the drop, but as you say the squad is so unbalanced it beggars belief that the bloke that caused it was a so called professional football coach.
|
|
|
Post by Gas Go Marching In on Dec 2, 2020 23:22:26 GMT
Yeah what have we done? We sacked one of the worst managers in the history of our club? With an atrocious record? Who assembled one of the most unbalanced, inexperienced, inept squads I've seen as a gashead. How terrible. What did we do letting him sign 4 left backs? What did we do letting him sell our best striker, release more or less all the rest, and only sign a kid, a player who hasn't played a league game before, and a striker who's renowned for not being a goalscorer and leaving us exposed to injury? What did we do letting him release Tony Craig and letting him replace him with Max Ehmer and Jack Baldwin What did we do letting him force out Abu Ogogo who wore his heart on his sleeve and bled blue blood for us? and Replacing him with Grant who can't be assed to go for a second ball and run back after that second ball? What did we do? Just because he could get the best out of his sh** squad over 3 fixtures doesn't make him worthy of the managers position or mean the new manager aint any good. Spot on. Only one person responsible for this and he was rightly shown the door. How on earth people can blame Tisdale after less than two weeks in the job is beyond me. Hopefully PT can sort us out sufficiently to avoid the drop, but as you say the squad is so unbalanced it beggars belief that the bloke that caused it was a so called professional football coach. I agree with you Bideford yet still some people would give him more time. I was called a brainlesscancerous idiot and for wanting Garner gone yet the same person has written Tisdale off before he's barely got a foot in the door.
|
|
|
Post by theduke on Dec 3, 2020 19:36:24 GMT
Anybody holding Tisdale responsible for anything at the moment is a lunatic. This is not his mess, but he's got to get it right in January otherwise this squad of players is going down.
We need TW to pull another JCH out of the hat.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 3, 2020 20:46:47 GMT
Anybody holding Tisdale responsible for anything at the moment is a lunatic. This is not his mess, but he's got to get it right in January otherwise this squad of players is going down. We need TW to pull another JCH out of the hat. Can we blame him for tactics,subs and formations?
|
|
|
Post by kampucheagas on Dec 3, 2020 21:06:26 GMT
Anybody holding Tisdale responsible for anything at the moment is a lunatic. This is not his mess, but he's got to get it right in January otherwise this squad of players is going down. We need TW to pull another JCH out of the hat. Can we blame him for tactics,subs and formations? To an extent but it’s not his fault for the crap unbalanced bench he has to choose from!
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 3, 2020 21:18:11 GMT
Yeah what have we done? We sacked one of the worst managers in the history of our club? With an atrocious record? Who assembled one of the most unbalanced, inexperienced, inept squads I've seen as a gashead. How terrible. What did we do letting him sign 4 left backs? What did we do letting him sell our best striker, release more or less all the rest, and only sign a kid, a player who hasn't played a league game before, and a striker who's renowned for not being a goalscorer and leaving us exposed to injury? What did we do letting him release Tony Craig and letting him replace him with Max Ehmer and Jack Baldwin What did we do letting him force out Abu Ogogo who wore his heart on his sleeve and bled blue blood for us? and Replacing him with Grant who can't be assed to go for a second ball and run back after that second ball? What did we do? Just because he could get the best out of his sh** squad over 3 fixtures doesn't make him worthy of the managers position or mean the new manager aint any good. He didn't sell our best striker im pretty sure that was down to the board excepting an offer and a player who didn't want to be here. Abu Ogogo is not good enough I don't ever get that argument all the stats tell you he was declining as a player. The players who got released were on contracts that we could no longer afford but we should have kept them so we could end up losing more money. I'm glad you are not running the club as we would be wound up in no time at all.The club had a strategy of bringing in younger players which alot agreed with the view to selling the better ones on so we could be self sufficient nothing has changed. I agree some of the signings were head scratching but the board sanctioned them all so it's not all BGs fault others have to take some blame for the recruitment. 3 strikers was a mistake but as the system we were playing only had one up front I can see why he choose to go that way. I believe the board jumped to quickly and now we are going to see exactly the same as what happened last season when our manager decided to quit. Yeah we all get the logic but what he failed to do was plan to fail. It’s a head scratcher to me that a man with no experience went to the board and said “I want to play 4-5-1, I only need three strikers” and nobody thought say “but what if 4-5-1 doesn’t work? What if you decide you need 2 strikers on the pitch regularly?” When you read it back it beggars belief that someone who had no idea what managing a team was like was able to build a squad around a single formation. I’m laughing as I type this out because it’s just...ridiculous really. As gasandelectricity said the people who sanctioned this are culpable as Garner is. Tinpot amateur stuff and we could all see it a mile off as soon as JCH was sold.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 3, 2020 22:40:50 GMT
Leave ben alone. He's done a grand job.
|
|
|
Post by BishopstonBRFC on Dec 4, 2020 6:52:45 GMT
He didn't sell our best striker im pretty sure that was down to the board excepting an offer and a player who didn't want to be here. Abu Ogogo is not good enough I don't ever get that argument all the stats tell you he was declining as a player. The players who got released were on contracts that we could no longer afford but we should have kept them so we could end up losing more money. I'm glad you are not running the club as we would be wound up in no time at all.The club had a strategy of bringing in younger players which alot agreed with the view to selling the better ones on so we could be self sufficient nothing has changed. I agree some of the signings were head scratching but the board sanctioned them all so it's not all BGs fault others have to take some blame for the recruitment. 3 strikers was a mistake but as the system we were playing only had one up front I can see why he choose to go that way. I believe the board jumped to quickly and now we are going to see exactly the same as what happened last season when our manager decided to quit. Yeah we all get the logic but what he failed to do was plan to fail. It’s a head scratcher to me that a man with no experience went to the board and said “I want to play 4-5-1, I only need three strikers” and nobody thought say “but what if 4-5-1 doesn’t work? What if you decide you need 2 strikers on the pitch regularly?” When you read it back it beggars belief that someone who had no idea what managing a team was like was able to build a squad around a single formation. I’m laughing as I type this out because it’s just...ridiculous really. As gasandelectricity said the people who sanctioned this are culpable as Garner is. Tinpot amateur stuff and we could all see it a mile off as soon as JCH was sold. Maybe they did say that but Ben told them he was happy enough with what we had in the development squad if he needed to call on another striker? Maybe he thought Nicholson could be the 4th striker if really needed?
|
|
|
Post by goodnightirene1883 on Dec 4, 2020 8:35:54 GMT
Yeah we all get the logic but what he failed to do was plan to fail. It’s a head scratcher to me that a man with no experience went to the board and said “I want to play 4-5-1, I only need three strikers” and nobody thought say “but what if 4-5-1 doesn’t work? What if you decide you need 2 strikers on the pitch regularly?” When you read it back it beggars belief that someone who had no idea what managing a team was like was able to build a squad around a single formation. I’m laughing as I type this out because it’s just...ridiculous really. As gasandelectricity said the people who sanctioned this are culpable as Garner is. Tinpot amateur stuff and we could all see it a mile off as soon as JCH was sold. Maybe they did say that but Ben told them he was happy enough with what we had in the development squad if he needed to call on another striker? Maybe he thought Nicholson could be the 4th striker if really needed? I could see Nicholson playing up there in the short term with Brandon mate. I think the Gills played a 4312 formation. Could that work for us? Hanlan and Nicolson with Ozzy just behind. Then the best combo of McCormick (if fit), Westy, Grant, Liddle, Barrett, Hargreaves, Upson, Harries (seems to get the DM position under PT) Just a thought
|
|
|
Post by wilmslowgas on Dec 4, 2020 13:29:16 GMT
Anybody holding Tisdale responsible for anything at the moment is a lunatic. This is not his mess, but he's got to get it right in January otherwise this squad of players is going down. We need TW to pull another JCH out of the hat. Can we blame him for tactics,subs and formations? We need more than another JCH to rescue us. We are conceding too many goals and that has got to be addressed. As long as the defence stays tight you've always got a chance of nicking the three points. We need centre backs that rarely make mistakes; full backs/wing backs who know how to defend and stop crosses coming into the box; and central midfielders who stop the opposition flooding through. At present, our defensive set up shows very little of those qualities.
|
|
|
Post by bridgwatergas on Dec 4, 2020 15:39:47 GMT
Yeah we all get the logic but what he failed to do was plan to fail. It’s a head scratcher to me that a man with no experience went to the board and said “I want to play 4-5-1, I only need three strikers” and nobody thought say “but what if 4-5-1 doesn’t work? What if you decide you need 2 strikers on the pitch regularly?” When you read it back it beggars belief that someone who had no idea what managing a team was like was able to build a squad around a single formation. I’m laughing as I type this out because it’s just...ridiculous really. As gasandelectricity said the people who sanctioned this are culpable as Garner is. Tinpot amateur stuff and we could all see it a mile off as soon as JCH was sold. Maybe they did say that but Ben told them he was happy enough with what we had in the development squad if he needed to call on another striker? Maybe he thought Nicholson could be the 4th striker if really needed? It could well have been the case that they wanted to bring on someone from our youth ranks as that was the whole point of the project. I don't think losing all 3 strikers so early in the season would have entered there heads. BG gets alot of stick for the team but noone knows what happened behind the scenes. I also think we shouldn't have sacked him as PT will need more than 2 or 3 months to get things anywhere near what he wants and we don't have that time. This is just how last season went when GC left the players had a complete pre season being shown what way they are expected to play to have all torn up 2 months into the season and now have to try to get to grips with Tisdales way of playing with very limited time on the training ground.
|
|