|
Post by I Voted For Kodos on Dec 28, 2014 17:49:58 GMT
Same as ever, all opinions appreciated:
Puddy
Leadbitter McChyrstal Parkes Lockyer
Gosling Mansell Sinclair Gosling
Taylor Blissett
Subs: Clarke Goldberg Harrison
DC Ref Macclesfield
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 28, 2014 18:26:51 GMT
Puddy 6 not a lot to do Leadbitter 7 another good game following on from Torquay Parkes 8 looking really solid McChrystal 8 slipped back in no problem Lockyer 7 defended well not so good going forward as Brown Gosling 7 two good displays unlucky not to score first half Mansell 7 another no nonsense game Sinclair 7 so consistant at what he does Monkhouse 8 not as involved as some but scored the all important first and made the just as important second Taylor 8 Another good goal and unlucky with another effort,good all round game Blissset 6 finished well for his goal,still a little off the pace at times but so much potential
Clarke 5 nearly scored but gave the ball away to much Harrison 6 made an impact and stuck the pen away Goldberg 6 made an impact and won the pen
DC 8 good tactics and has created a good work ethic,more people are starting to believe me included
Ref 6 some strange decisions,but getting used to it in this league
Maccs 5 we made a usefull team look ordinary
Fans 7 the belief is building
|
|
|
Post by Russgas on Dec 28, 2014 18:37:07 GMT
Puddy 7 Hardly anything to do but looks very comfortable,his distribution was good.
Leadbitter 8 Pick of the defenders. McChyrstal 7.5 Very strong display Parkes 7.5 looks a lot fitter now than start of the season. Lockyer 7 Excellent display considering his position.
Gosling 7 Looks good when he runs at defenders and needs to do this more. Excellent delivery from his crossing today. Mansell 7 was under par first half but had a very good second. Sinclair 7.5 Fantastic all round effort. Monkhouse 7.5 Great header for his goal and clever assist as well.Put in a good shift.
Taylor 8 Was a class act.Pulled Maccy all over the place and took his goal well. Blissett 7 Very workman like,won loads of headers and got on the scoresheet.
Subs: Clarke 6 Got in some crunching tackles and broke up play well. Goldberg 6 looks lively with the ball played to feet and did very well with his turn of pace to win the penalty. Harrison 6.5 Now thats how to dispatch a penalty.
DC 8.5 Got us playing some great stuff atm. Well done DC. Ref 7 one of the better ones. Macclesfield 5 They looked generally well organized but in the end just got totally blown away. Fans 9 Loads of singing today and a free light show as well.
|
|
|
Post by WeAreTheGas on Dec 28, 2014 18:59:21 GMT
Puddy 6 - Quiet day at the office thanks to a solid defence, but did what he had to competently.
Leadbitter 7 - Was beaten by their winger a couple of times early on, but defended well for the rest of it & his pace is an asset on the overlap. McChyrstal 7 - Solid. Parkes 7 - Solid. Lockyer 6 - Solid, but his distribution leaves a lot to be desired at times. Doing a fine job filling in at LB though.
Gosling 6 - Had a good first half but faded in the second. Hit the post after good play. Mansell 7 - Holds the midfield together and shields the back four brilliantly. Sinclair 6 - Not involved too much today, but constant energy and pressing in midfield is valuable. Monkhouse 8 - Scored the all important first goal and excellent wing play to assist for Blissett.
Taylor 8 - Pace, movement and touch caused their defence problems all game. Starting to add the goals to his game that make him the complete striker at this level. Blissett 6 - Looks a little off the pace atm, but his physical assets alone make him a nightmare to play against. Scored.
Subs: Clarke 6 - Quiet. Goldberg 6 - Didn't have much time to impact, but did well to win the penalty. Harrison 6 - Well taken penalty.
DC 8 - Not a great first half, but must have said the right things at HT to fire the boys up. Ref 6 Macclesfield 4 - Organised but toothless in first half, and just toothless in the second.
|
|
|
Post by gashead22 on Dec 28, 2014 18:59:50 GMT
Puddy - 6 Not much to do and kicking a bit off. Nothing to report.
Leadbitter - 7 Best performance i've seen from him. Dominant in the air and quick going forward. McChyrstal - 9 (My MOtM) Outstanding. Best defender on the pitch, won every header and captained the team well. Parkes - 8 Back to his best Lockyer - 6 Good defensively, poor distribution/attacking intent. His versatility is a real asset though.
Gosling - 7 Excellent delivery from set pieces and some great crosses. Didn't take on the full back as much as i'd have liked especially first half. Mansell - 7.5 Solid Sinclair - 7.5 Usual self Monkhouse - 8 Excellent game and heavily involved in first 2 crucial goals. His touch is brilliant, brings class to the side.
Taylor - 8 Excellent display, held ball up well and linked up with Blisset at times. Should have had 2 but still got on the score sheet. Blissett - 6.5 Showed glimpses but only grew into the game after about an hour. Struggled to hold the ball up at times. Could be a very good player though.
Subs: Clarke - 6 Ok, nothing special Goldberg - 6 Won the pen, looked a bit rusty but did ok Harrison - 6.5 Looked very lively and put the pen away well
DC - 9 Spot on Ref - 7 Decent ref, few dodgy decisions but mainly lino's fault. Got all major stuff right imo. Macclesfield - 5 Nothing special, ok defensively until we put a couple past them
|
|
|
Post by smudge1 on Dec 28, 2014 19:03:44 GMT
Puddy 7 Not much to do but what he had to he did well
Leadbitter 8 Best I have seen him play McChyrstal 8.5 Solid, thought Trotman should have stayed in but good shout by DC Parkes 8 Well back to his best Lockyer 7 Not a full back, but did his best playing on his wrong side
Gosling 7.5 Wow much improved performance than of late Mansell 8 Consistently good and the calming influence we need Sinclair 8 Typical Duracell bunny Monkhouse 8.5 Best performance from him this season
Taylor 8.5 Fantastic play off the ball now getting it right with the ball Blissett 8 A constant menace that defenders hate
Subs: Clarke 7.5 Played his typical game Goldberg 7 Did nothing wrong but cannot get in with Taylor playing like he does Harrison 7 Good penalty but not quite good enough for a regular place
DC 9 Spot on with selection and subs Ref 7 Not too bad Macclesfield 5 Must have a small squad and players on show today were no great shakes Fans 9 Back to our best well done!
|
|
|
Post by wysemangas on Dec 28, 2014 19:35:59 GMT
Puddy 6 Not much to do, good game to ease back
Leadbitter 7 Another good game, beginning to play with more consistency McChrystal 7.5 Don't know why Trotman was dropped but McC showed why Parkes 7.5 Solid and now very consistent in every game Lockyer 7 Mr. Versatile
Gosling 6 Another good display, Mansell 7 Solid and dependable Sinclair 7 What can you say about this guy, Mr. Fantastic Monkhouse 7.5 Probably his best game yet.
Taylor 8 Showing why DC had so much faith in him Blissett 6 Have we a more skilful Devon White in our squad
Subs Clarke 5 We played in Blue and White but won a few tackles Goldberg 5 Won a penalty Harrison 5 Took penalty well DC 8 Back him
Ref 5 Typical of this division, sometimes spot on sometimes baffling
Macclesfield 4 Expected a bit more from them Fans 8 Lets hope we are as good, when things don't go to plan
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 28, 2014 19:51:32 GMT
Puddy 6 Leadbitter 7.5 McChrystal 7 Parkes 7 Lockyer 7 Gosling 7.5 Mansell 7 Sinclair 7 Monkhouse 8 Taylor 7.5 Blissett 7
Clarke 5 Goldburg 5 Harrison 5
DC 8 Ref 7 Macclesfield 5
|
|
|
Post by Staffordshire Gas on Dec 28, 2014 20:01:50 GMT
Pleased for Leadbitter .Much maligned early in the season but thought how well he did at Lincoln and Torquay.Coming good.
|
|
|
Post by markczgas on Dec 28, 2014 21:31:01 GMT
Puddy 6 steady performance
Lockyer 6 Poor first half with the ball - he seems blind to giving a short pass at times, improved after the break McChrystal 7 Strong no-nonsense display, improved passing Parkes 8 Excellent, aggressive, controlled display. Leadbitter 7 Defended well against Macc's better left-sided players, closed players down well.
Gosling 6 Why oh why did he square the ball early on ? One great cross for Taylor 2nd half, and better movement from him. Still won't trust his right and go on the outside. Monkhouse 7 very good game, good goal and set up for Blast Mansell 8 A rolls royce performance - didn't want to give the ball to them, calm with his play at all times Sinclair 7 Efficient, hardworking display
Taylor 8 My MOM - great lay-offs and touches, demands the ball all the time and troubled Macc with his movement. Deserved his goal so much. Blisset 6 Good finish, I thought he was a bit slow to read flick ons and balls to him first half. got better second half.
Clarke 5 A bit off the pace, one good strike which probably should've been on target Harrison 5 Thumped home the pen, but his touch wasn't great Goldberg 5 Had a go a couple of times but it didn't go for him
Clarke 9 Excellent display by the team. They really knocked Macc off their stride and Rovers started to play some really good stuff ( interplay, ball on the deck more, GREAT PRESSING without the ball) and plenty of team spirit and understanding Ref 8 - very good. did he cock up with that corner that Puddy ket in ?? Macc 3 - couldn't get anywhere with our midfield and then later their defence caved in
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 28, 2014 22:41:42 GMT
Puddy 7 Leadbitter 7 McChrystal 7 Parkes 7 Lockyer 7 Gosling 7.5 Mansell 7 Sinclair 7.5 Monkhouse 8 Taylor 7.5 Blissett 7
Clarke 5 Goldburg 5 Harrison 5
DC 8 Ref 7 Macclesfield 5
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 28, 2014 23:50:30 GMT
Puddy 6
Leadbitter 8 McChyrstal 8 Parkes 7 Lockyer 6
Gosling 7 Mansell 7 Sinclair 7 Monkkhouse 8
Taylor 8 Blissett 6
Subs: Clarke 5 Goldberg 6 Harrison 6
DC 8 Ref 7 Macclesfield 5
|
|
|
Post by I Voted For Kodos on Dec 29, 2014 0:56:59 GMT
Can't really make individual comments on the game as it was such a team performance. We always looked comfortable in the game and Macclesfield struggled to get anything going. Everyone has complete confidence in everyone else and we play as a unit which is so great to see.
Puddy 7
Leadbitter 8 McChrystal 7.5 Parkes 7.5 Lockyer 7.5
Gosling 8 Mansell 8 Sinclair 7.5 Monkhouse 8.5
Taylor 8 Blissett 7.5
Subs: Clarke 6.5 Goldberg 6 Harrison 6
DC 8 Ref 7 Macclesfield 5
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 29, 2014 8:58:45 GMT
Puddy 6
Leadbitter 6.5 Parkes 7.5 Macca 7 Lockyer 7
Mansell 7 Sinclair 7 Gosling 7 Monkhouse 7.5
Blissett 6.5 Taylor 8 MOTM
Harrison 6.5 Goldberg 6 Clarke 6
DC 8
Ref 6
Mac 7
|
|
|
Post by Wembley_Gas on Dec 29, 2014 20:39:08 GMT
Puddy 7 just one dodgy kick Leadbitter 7 never outpaced Lockyer 7 Mr Versatility never let's us down Parkes 8 now in a rich vein of form McChrystal 8 unfussy and commanding Monkhouse 8 showing what an asset he can be now Mansell 8 mopped up and drove us on Sinclair 8 everywhere Gosling 7 creative out wide Taylor 7 tied up the Macc defence Blissett 7 the pacey big man worried his markers throughout
Clarke 7 buttoned things up Harrison - useful cameo but not on long enough for a mark Goldberg - useful cameo but not on long enough for a mark
DC 9 MOTM inspired the whole team to raise their game in the second half when some managers we have had would have been content to sit on the one nil lead. Eight of the starting XI were DC acquisitions
Macc 5 I guess it was down to injuries but they seemed way short of the abilities of Gateshead and Barnet.
Crowd 9 a pleasure being amongst you!
Ref 6 more than I have given most refs at this level!
|
|
|
Post by I Voted For Kodos on Dec 30, 2014 12:52:56 GMT
Results are in and Andy Monkhouse just snatched Man of the Match from Matty Taylor by a margin of 0.5 across 14 ratings. All 14 players involved against Macclesfield performed above their season averages, so no sign of Christmas fatigue yet. The last 4 games have seen 4 different midfielders claim the Man of the Match award. This was rated as the second best performance of the season and the best at home. The starting XI average 7.26 only behind the 7.32 in the draw at Eastleigh. This was also rated as Darrell Clarke's best performance other than the Eastleigh game (8.5).
Puddy 6.4
Leadbitter 7.4 McChrystal 7.6 Parkes 7.6 Lockyer 6.8
Gosling 7.0 Mansell 7.4 Sinclair 7.3 Monkhouse 7.93 MotM
Taylor 7.89 Blissett 6.7
Subs: Clarke 5.8 Goldberg 5.8 Harrison 5.9
DC 8.3 Ref 6.6 Macclesfield 4.9
|
|