|
Post by I Voted For Kodos on Dec 17, 2022 17:16:43 GMT
Belshaw
Thomas Connolly Gibson
Sinclair Coutts McCormick Evans Gordon
Collins Coburn
Subs: Hoole Marquis Whelan Gibbons
Ref Charlton
|
|
|
Post by smudge1 on Dec 17, 2022 17:36:42 GMT
Belshaw 8 Thomas 6 Connolly 5 Gibsin 6 Evans 7 McCormick 5 Coutts 6 Sinclair 6 Collins 6 Coburn 5 Gordon 6.5
Hoole 6 Marquis 8.5 MOM Whelan Nole Gibbons Nole
Ref 6 Charlton 4
|
|
|
Post by GasHeadBlues on Dec 17, 2022 17:47:05 GMT
Belshaw 8.5 Kept us in the game first half
Thomas 6 Connolly 4 Really didn't seem himself today Gibson 6.5
Sinclair 6 Poor first half, second half much better after Hoole came on Coutts 5.5 McCormick 4 Sadly he still looks lost Evans 8 A couple of wayward crosses but he's beginning to look the class player we had last season, none stop energy and the only outfield player to play well over the 90 minutes. Gordon 7 Decent from the lad.
Collins 5 Not involved enough Coburn 6 Poor first half, improved second.
Subs: Hoole 7 Made a big difference Marquis 8 He's the Man at the moment Whelan nole but worth a 7 on his short visit Gibbons nole
Ref 7 Charlton 6
|
|
|
Post by bidefordgas on Dec 17, 2022 17:54:55 GMT
Belshaw 8 Thomas 6.5 Connolly 6.5 Gibson 6.5 Sinclair 4 Evans 7.5 McCormick 4 Coutts 6.5 Gordon 6.5 Collins 6 Coburn 6
Hoole 7 Marquis 8 Whelan nole Gibbons nole
Ref 7 Charlton 6
|
|
|
Post by percy on Dec 17, 2022 18:09:03 GMT
Belshaw 8
Thomas 8 Connolly 6 Gibson 7
Sinclair 5 Coutts 7 McCormick 6 Evans 8 Gordon 8
Collins 7 Coburn 8
Subs: Hoole 9 Marquis 9.5 Whelan 7 Gibbons nole
Ref 7 Charlton 6 (8 first half 4 second)
|
|
|
Post by Russgas on Dec 17, 2022 18:20:44 GMT
Belshaw 8
Thomas 7 Connolly 4 Gibson 7
Sinclair 6 Coutts 6 McCormick 5 Evans 7 Gordon 6.5
Collins 7 Coburn 7
Subs: Hoole 7 Marquis 8.5 Whelan NOLE Gibbons NOLE
Ref 8 Charlton 6
|
|
|
Post by cheamgas on Dec 17, 2022 20:54:57 GMT
Belshaw 8
Thomas 6 Connolly 5 Gibson 5.5
Sinclair 4 Coutts 6 McCormick 4 Evans 6 Gordon 6
Collins 5 Coburn 6
Subs: Hoole 6.5 Marquis 8.5 Whelan nole Gibbons nole
Ref 6 Charlton 6
|
|
|
Post by seanclevedongas on Dec 17, 2022 21:24:05 GMT
Belshaw 8 kept us in in the first half
Thomas 7 Connolly 6 Gibson 7
Sinclair 5 Coutts 7 McCormick 5 Evans 7 Gordon 5
Collins 5 Coburn 7
Subs: Hoole 8 great to see the subs making such an impact Marquis 8 Whelan 7 Gibbons nole
Ref 0 Charlton 5
|
|
|
Post by meadgas on Dec 17, 2022 21:39:40 GMT
Belshaw 8 Thomas 7 Connolly 6 Gibson 7 Sinclair 5 Coutts 7 McCormick 5 Evans 7.5 Gordon 6.5 Collins 5.5 Coburn 6 Subs: Hoole 7.5 Marquis 8.5 Whelan nole Gibbons nole Ref 6 Charlton 5
|
|
|
Post by o2o2bo2ba on Dec 17, 2022 21:48:16 GMT
From ifollow..
Belshaw 9 m o m kept us in it first half and mom by courtesy of the most consistent all through match, not a foot wrong. Matchsaver!
Thomas 6 erratic. Connolly 5 ponderous. Gibson 8 steadying force.
Sinclair 5 offered little (ironically similar to Little a few years earlier). Coutts 8 excellent skip needless booking but brilliant assist for 2nd.. McCormick 7 tried hard just didn't quite work for him. Evans 5 missed his boat but second half was inspirational. Gordon 4 poor and offered nothing. Losing patience and don't get it?
Collins 6 worked hard but not his day. Coburn 8 never stopped running and played lone striker as gleeming first half light ...
Subs: Hoole 7.5 done well to affect shape change and won his headers but almost got caught once. Marquis 8.5 super sub! Whelan nole. Gibbons nole.
Ref 7.5 no complaints. Charlton 5 should have put us to the sword, but you can see BG training by playing ball out when not comfy and subsequently paid the price.....we celebrate our tents at mem and marquis away!
Famous Gas win and credit to travelling vocal support!
|
|
clovis
Reserve Team
Posts: 333
|
Post by clovis on Dec 18, 2022 12:05:01 GMT
Odd game as we were so below par for 30 minutes at least but got better and better.
Belshaw. 8.5 Good saves
Thomas. 7. Good player Gibson. 6.5. Didn’t look any better than Connolly in the first half. Connolly. 6. Didn’t look right.
Coutts. 7.5 Nice assist for the second. McCormick 6.5 I thought he did OK in the first half. We could do with him stepping up if Rossiter is out for a while. Gordon. 6.5. I forgot he was playing for a while. Sinclair 7. Got better in the second half along with everyone else. Evans. 7.5. Did well.
Collins. 7. No service in the first half. Much better in the second. Coburn. 7.5. We’re lucky to have him.
Subs Hoole. 7.5. Did very well I thought. Involved a lot. Good to see. Marquis. 8.5 and MoM. Wasn’t sure he had it in him but what a fantastic cameo. Loved both goals. Whelan. 7. A couple of calm touches. Someone else came on to waste some time, forget who, but NOLE.
Ref. 7. Nothing too stupid. Charlton. 5. Tore us apart for 20 minutes but nothing much afterwards. Strange performance, the Garner effect maybe.
|
|
|
Post by Sir Trevor on Dec 18, 2022 12:59:14 GMT
James Belshaw - 8.0 (Despite two very risky decisions he enables the team to play on the front foot)
Bobby Thomas - 8.0 (While he is not the best on the ball this side of his game is developing) James Connolly - 6.0 Lewis Gibson - 8.0 (Quietly goes about his work in a calm and purposeful manner)
Scott Sinclair - 6.5 Paul Coutts - 7.5 Luke McCormick - 6.0 (Still not playing with the confidence, authority and edginess he can) Anthony Evans - 7.0 Lewis Gordon - 7.5
Aaron Collins - 7.0 Josh Coburn - 7.5
Substitutes Luca Hoole - 8.5 (Delighted to see his MK Dons performance was replicated here) John Marquis - 9.0 (In both fixtures this past week he has shown his teammates how to feed him) Glenn Whelan - 6.5 James Gibbons - NOLE
Referee - 7.5 (Surprised that none of the CAFC players were booked.)
Charlton Athletic - 6.0 (We did it - at last)
|
|
|
Post by peterhooper57 on Dec 18, 2022 17:22:23 GMT
Belshaw 9
Thomas 8 Connolly 7 Ill Gibson 8
Sinclair 6 Coutts 8 McCormick 6 Evans 7 Gordon 6
Collins 7 Coburn 8
Subs: Hoole 7 Marquis 9 Whelan 7 Gibbons DNP
Ref Charlton 7
|
|
|
Post by lisbongas on Dec 18, 2022 23:06:12 GMT
Belshaw top display first half, second half quiet until last few mins. 8
Thomas Better in the air then on the floor, we needed his strength against a big set of forwards he did well 7.5 Connolly not sure if he was ill but looked off the pace and ponderous on ball too much pointless passing not helped by Coutts constantly coming deep and playing ball back.6 Gibson best game to date looked assured throughout 8
Sinclair poor first half often out of position and not s competent display at wingback. Better second half 6 Coutts overplayed ball in first half, too many loose passes or overshot intended player came to deep closing down the options for Connelly. Better second half when time woke up 6 McCormick he did ok and we need to persevere. Some good tackles neat passing but undermined by sloppy play 6 Evans best of our midfield, second half display gets MOTM for me 8.5 Gordon solid defensively but offered little going forward 6.5
Collins a bad day at the office, didn't close down a sloppy back three. 5 Coburn poor service but did little first half. Second half more involved and posed a bigger threat 7
Subs: Hoole very good in defence and attack after coming on 8 Marquis closed and harried and dragged us back into the game. May have done enough to start next week. 8 Whelan steady but nole Gibbons nole
Ref inconsistent booked Evan's for a pull back but not Charlton players for same offence 6
Charlton just had to read their fans write up to know they have centrehalves who struggle on the ball and yet it wasn't until marquis came on that we put them under pressure 5
|
|
|
Post by westfieldgas on Dec 19, 2022 9:35:03 GMT
Belshaw 7.4
Thomas 8.7 Connolly 7.1 Gibson 6.6
Sinclair 6.9 Coutts 6.9 McCormick 5.9 Evans 6.8 Gordon 6.7
Collins 8.9 Coburn 8.8
Subs: Hoole 6.7 Marquis 9.1 MOTM, Game Changer Whelan 6.8 Gibbons 6.8
Ref 6 Charlton 3
|
|
|
Post by I Voted For Kodos on Dec 19, 2022 11:33:30 GMT
Results in and John Marquis was Man of the Match with a score of 8.54.
The starting XI average was 6.58.
Belshaw 8.2
Thomas 7.1 Connolly 5.7 Gibson 7.0
Sinclair 5.6 Coutts 6.7 McCormick 5.4 Evans 7.1 Gordon 6.4
Collins 6.2 Coburn 7.0
Subs: Hoole 7.4 Marquis 8.5 Whelan 6.9 Gibbons 6.8
Ref 6.2 Charlton 5.4
|
|
gruad
Reserve Team
Posts: 325
|
Post by gruad on Dec 25, 2022 4:38:04 GMT
Thanks for keeping track of this for me. Great Result!
|
|