|
Post by percy on Oct 25, 2024 8:36:21 GMT
To maximise revenue per fan, I would always close the away terrace unless all away seating is sold. not sure we can (without their agreement). Home fans can buy terrace at a price point that must also be offered to away fans, or something like that?
|
|
|
Post by A Source (aka Angry Badger) on Oct 25, 2024 8:57:15 GMT
I'm being a bit facetious, but in relation to the two answers to my question; i) The South Stand is all metal; there's nothing to burn. And ii) Regarding segregation; why can't the matting just be moved? I thought the segregation within the concourse could be moved therefore opening up another entrance to seats for larger away support. If it can't be moved - massive error - then they'd be concerns about number of people using one entrance/exit
|
|
|
Post by oldmarket65 on Oct 25, 2024 10:28:53 GMT
I'm being a bit facetious, but in relation to the two answers to my question; i) The South Stand is all metal; there's nothing to burn. And ii) Regarding segregation; why can't the matting just be moved? I thought the segregation within the concourse could be moved therefore opening up another entrance to seats for larger away support. If it can't be moved - massive error - then they'd be concerns about number of people using one entrance/exit My understanding is the capacity is set at 1400 away fans for leauge games due to the constraints I mentioned. Unless of course they have done extensive work in the south stand ( exit points : rear segregation etc). Cup games & friendlies can be more flexible due to non ST holders.
|
|
|
Post by donvittorio on Oct 25, 2024 11:12:17 GMT
We used to give the whole of old South stand to away fans for big games (e.g. Leeds always filled it), presumably that was the same turnstiles as we have now?
|
|
|
Post by lockleazer on Oct 25, 2024 12:13:13 GMT
I believe we are still under restrictions in the South stand regarding crowd control and health and safety and it's not yet able to be used to full capacity, I seem to remember various warnings about standing and seating in allocated seating so that the club could fulfill obligations needed to get the restrictions lifted
|
|
|
Post by Sir Trevor on Oct 25, 2024 12:20:39 GMT
There is likely to be some small flexibility in the capacity for Away fans in the South Stand in future. Not loads. Fair enough.
BUT.
Three thoughts:
1. Extending the capacity for Away fans in the South Stand so that they have a more central presence is unwise. A large and growing list of clubs are exploring the ways in which visiting fans are not in a prime position behind a goalmouth.
Splitting up away supporters into discrete sections, moving away fans to corners or placing away fans high up is the noticeable trend.
In extending the space in the South Stand for away fans home supporters will need to be moved towards the fringes. The creation of a neutral or dead zone behind the goalmouth would be far from desirable.
Ideally, home fans directly behind both goalmouths is a desirable strategy for the future. South Stand central seats full of home supporting season ticket holders should be the long term aim and seats in a section like the MKJ stand should be sold last. Away fans in the corner of a new East Stand? Sounds good.
2. The income gained from ticket sales from a very large away following seems good. Appears good only. However, a range of changed working practices and arrangements for stadium staff will be an outcome of the different set-up.
Larger than normal away numbers may well require additional facilities to be provided and significant numbers of extra temporary staff who need careful vetting and training. Food outlets, bars and toilet provision are examples of facilities that may need to be increased if larger away followings are permitted.
The entry and egress structure cannot easily be adjusted for the untypical crowd size. Similarly, the required circulation areas for visiting supporters is not very flexible at The Memorial Stsdium at present.
One of the biggest costs likely to be incurred will be the not inconsiderable cost of extra safety stewards and the inevitable policing provision. Car and coach parking provision for away teams with larger than normal followings remain a clear challenge.
It is worth calculating the cost of the "extra provision" against the "extra income" accrued. It may not be worth it.
3. It might be helpful to reflect on the outcome of past fixtures at The Mem at which "hordes" took over the South Stand area. Did it help us to beat Leeds United, WBA or FGR in their promotion season?
Once or twice it helped. Ricky Lambert has scored a cracker against someone. There are few other times where these "hordes" went away disappointed.
With a full to capacity South Stand that is increased in size now the noise and atmosphere created can be loud and impressive. It could prove to be intimidating if it is full of away supporters.
It IS great to enjoy the atmosphere and hear the supporters in full voice when it is full of Home fans.
Long term we need to fill it.
Those who attended the Cardiff City pre season "friendly" can recall how their fans belted out their anthems. Yet they only had the allocation that is typically provided. If they had been given more of the South Stand they would have totally drowned out the home support.
This type of impact will occur if and when the money-minded short termism prevails.
Getting kicked out of cups, dropping points, getting relegated. OK. This can and will happen anyway. Letting "hordes" take over critical sections of the stadium for the short- term financial benefit will make it happen more often.
Finally. The aim has to be. Fill the South Stand with Home supporters.
|
|
|
Post by bidefordgas on Oct 25, 2024 12:44:43 GMT
I believe we are still under restrictions in the South stand regarding crowd control and health and safety and it's not yet able to be used to full capacity, I seem to remember various warnings about standing and seating in allocated seating so that the club could fulfill obligations needed to get the restrictions lifted How do you come to that conclusion when the likes of the Bolton game virtually filled the stand with only half of block g left empty with the away/ home fans blanket in place.
|
|
|
Post by oldmarket65 on Oct 25, 2024 12:59:00 GMT
There is likely to be some small flexibility in the capacity for Away fans in the South Stand in future. Not loads. Fair enough. BUT. Three thoughts: 1. Extending the capacity for Away fans in the South Stand so that they have a more central presence is unwise. A large and growing list of clubs are exploring the ways in which visiting fans are not in a prime position behind a goalmouth. Splitting up away supporters into discrete sections, moving away fans to corners or placing away fans high up is the noticeable trend. In extending the space in the South Stand for away fans home supporters will need to be moved towards the fringes. The creation of a neutral or dead zone behind the goalmouth would be far from desirable. Ideally, home fans directly behind both goalmouths is a desirable strategy for the future. South Stand central seats full of home supporting season ticket holders should be the long term aim and seats in a section like the MKJ stand should be sold last. Away fans in the corner of a new East Stand? Sounds good. 2. The income gained from ticket sales from a very large away following seems good. Appears good only. However, a range of changed working practices and arrangements for stadium staff will be an outcome of the different set-up. Larger than normal away numbers may well require additional facilities to be provided and significant numbers of extra temporary staff who need careful vetting and training. Food outlets, bars and toilet provision are examples of facilities that may need to be increased if larger away followings are permitted. The entry and egress structure cannot easily be adjusted for the untypical crowd size. Similarly, the required circulation areas for visiting supporters is not very flexible at The Memorial Stsdium at present. One of the biggest costs likely to be incurred will be the not inconsiderable cost of extra safety stewards and the inevitable policing provision. Car and coach parking provision for away teams with larger than normal followings remain a clear challenge. It is worth calculating the cost of the "extra provision" against the "extra income" accrued. It may not be worth it. 3. It might be helpful to reflect on the outcome of past fixtures at The Mem at which "hordes" took over the South Stand area. Did it help us to beat Leeds United, WBA or FGR in their promotion season? Once or twice it helped. Ricky Lambert has scored a cracker against someone. There are few other times where these "hordes" went away disappointed. With a full to capacity South Stand that is increased in size now the noise and atmosphere created can be loud and impressive. It could prove to be intimidating if it is full of away supporters. It IS great to enjoy the atmosphere and hear the supporters in full voice when it is full of Home fans. Long term we need to fill it. Those who attended the Cardiff City pre season "friendly" can recall how their fans belted out their anthems. Yet they only had the allocation that is typically provided. If they had been given more of the South Stand they would have totally drowned out the home support. This type of impact will occur if and when the money-minded short termism prevails. Getting kicked out of cups, dropping points, getting relegated. OK. This can and will happen anyway. Letting "hordes" take over critical sections of the stadium for the short- term financial benefit will make it happen more often. Finally. The aim has to be. Fill the South Stand with Home supporters. I went to Cardiff freindly and they were able to have 1600 in South stand because there were NO st holders also cup games can be flexible . However with leauge games they are restricted to 650 terrace and 750 stand. Therefore the current away allocation is exactly the same as when we had the tents . This makes NO sense when we average 7500 in a 12k stadium. You mentioned away fans income may not be worth it ?. If true then what use would it be to extend the ground any further. We haven't averaged more than 12k for 55 years. Finally talking to fans from FGR swindon Cheltenham at cricket games . They are gutted the lost of the BIG 6 away followings in div one and the revenue it brought . These clubs would sweeze in away fans like sardines in a small can.
|
|
|
Post by wertongas on Oct 25, 2024 15:12:28 GMT
We used to give the whole of old South stand to away fans for big games (e.g. Leeds always filled it), presumably that was the same turnstiles as we have now? The new stand is three and a half times larger than the old tent, no way would the turnstiles be able to take all those supporters. For the first time in our history we have a decent sized all seat stand giving a better choice of where home fans can sit and you and some others want to hand it all over to the away team, madness.
I lost my seat in the west stand due to mistakes by the club and have landed up in the corner of the ground in the small family stand for the Weston game , I would have liked a better location in the south stand but home supporters can't use it. Birmingham supporters get to sit in decent sized stands every home game at least so why can't our home fans? , why do you want them kicked out the only decent all seater stand we have got.
If Weston fans need more room they can be put on the east terrace, then the sh*theads amongst them can feel the rain on their heads and cold wind around their ears.
|
|
|
Post by oldmarket65 on Oct 25, 2024 16:30:40 GMT
We used to give the whole of old South stand to away fans for big games (e.g. Leeds always filled it), presumably that was the same turnstiles as we have now? The new stand is three and a half times larger than the old tent, no way would the turnstiles be able to take all those supporters. For the first time in our history we have a decent sized all seat stand giving a better choice of where home fans can sit and you and some others want to hand it all over to the away team, madness.
I lost my seat in the west stand due to mistakes by the club and have landed up in the corner of the ground in the small family stand for the Weston game , I would have liked a better location in the south stand but home supporters can't use it. Birmingham supporters get to sit in decent sized stands every home game at least so why can't our home fans? , why do you want them kicked out the only decent all seater stand we have got.
If Weston fans need more room they can be put on the east terrace, then the sh*theads amongst them can feel the rain on their heads and cold wind around their ears.
Of course home fans need comfortable accessible family freindly facilities . However : the club needs to generate income to survive. It is equally madness to have 8500 home fans on CAT A games and only 1400 away fans . Thus leaving 2-3k empty for the sake of it. I think most fans would agree with both our points A) priority to home fans first . B) If there are up to 3000 empty places allow the away fans to increase allocation based on needs .
|
|
|
Post by A Source (aka Angry Badger) on Oct 25, 2024 16:35:20 GMT
We used to give the whole of old South stand to away fans for big games (e.g. Leeds always filled it), presumably that was the same turnstiles as we have now? The new stand is three and a half times larger than the old tent, no way would the turnstiles be able to take all those supporters. For the first time in our history we have a decent sized all seat stand giving a better choice of where home fans can sit and you and some others want to hand it all over to the away team, madness.
I lost my seat in the west stand due to mistakes by the club and have landed up in the corner of the ground in the small family stand for the Weston game , I would have liked a better location in the south stand but home supporters can't use it. Birmingham supporters get to sit in decent sized stands every home game at least so why can't our home fans? , why do you want them kicked out the only decent all seater stand we have got.
If Weston fans need more room they can be put on the east terrace, then the sh*theads amongst them can feel the rain on their heads and cold wind around their ears.
Not a bad idea. Imagine the Teds spending the last few years going to all these nice grounds where the roofs keep the smell in. I think giving them an outdated uncovered terrace might give them an afternoon of clean air..... apart from the gas.
|
|
|
Post by stokegiffordgas on Oct 25, 2024 17:58:34 GMT
To maximise revenue per fan, I would always close the away terrace unless all away seating is sold. I did wonder why Shrewsbury only had seats on Tuesday. Did they all want to sit down? Hopefully more money for us presuming stand is dearer than enclosure- - -
|
|
|
Post by Topper Gas on Oct 25, 2024 18:12:17 GMT
To maximise revenue per fan, I would always close the away terrace unless all away seating is sold. I did wonder why Shrewsbury only had seats on Tuesday. Did they all want to sit down? Hopefully more money for us presuming stand is dearer than enclosure- - - Don't we have to offer away fans the same lowest price as home fans, not sure we can force them to sit down/pay stand prices if we have terracing available?
|
|
|
Post by stokegiffordgas on Oct 25, 2024 18:44:51 GMT
Which I get but most home games away fans are in both enclosure and stand, why was Tuesday different?
|
|
|
Post by Topper Gas on Oct 25, 2024 19:03:42 GMT
|
|
yattongas
Forum Legend
Posts: 15,448
Member is Online
|
Post by yattongas on Oct 25, 2024 19:07:16 GMT
I'm being a bit facetious, but in relation to the two answers to my question; i) The South Stand is all metal; there's nothing to burn. And ii) Regarding segregation; why can't the matting just be moved? I thought the segregation within the concourse could be moved therefore opening up another entrance to seats for larger away support. If it can't be moved - massive error - then they'd be concerns about number of people using one entrance/exit It can’t be moved as it bolted in I think.
|
|
yattongas
Forum Legend
Posts: 15,448
Member is Online
|
Post by yattongas on Oct 25, 2024 19:07:48 GMT
|
|
|
Post by gasheadontour on Oct 25, 2024 21:17:41 GMT
I did wonder why Shrewsbury only had seats on Tuesday. Did they all want to sit down? Hopefully more money for us presuming stand is dearer than enclosure- - - Don't we have to offer away fans the same lowest price as home fans, not sure we can force them to sit down/pay stand prices if we have terracing available? I had thought it's equivalent pricing for the same facilities as home fans. Therefore could close away terrace and away fans pay for seating at the same price as home fans pay for seating?
|
|