|
Post by I Voted For Kodos on Oct 23, 2018 21:12:44 GMT
Bonham
Leadbitter Lockyer Craig Kelly
Matthews Upson Sercombe Bennett
O. Clarke
Nichols
Subs: J. Clarke Jakubiak Payne
Crowd Ref Wimbledon
|
|
|
Post by Russgas on Oct 23, 2018 21:27:45 GMT
Bonham 7.5
Leadbitter 6 Lockyer 7 Craig 7 Kelly 6.5
Matthews 5 Upson 7 Sercombe 5 Bennett 5
O. Clarke 5
Nichols 5
Subs: J. Clarke 6 Jakubiak 5 Payne nole
Crowd 6 Ref 4 Wimbledon 6
|
|
|
Post by CornishPasty_Gas on Oct 23, 2018 21:43:49 GMT
Bonham 8 - crucial saves and dominated his area
Leadbitter 5.5 - did ok but where are these skimming runs we have seen in the past 3 years? Lockyer 7 - solid Craig 7 - decent game Kelly 5.5 - doesn't fill me with confidence at all
Matthews 4.5 - far too lightweight and gets caught in possession too much. Upson 7.5 - steady and in the game a lot. Good performance Sercombe 5 - didn't do a lot. Ran about... Bennett 3 - waste of space. Offered nothing.
O. Clarke 5.5 - didn't do an awful lot wrong but went missing for me.
Nichols 6.5 - tried and ran and ran. Absolutely no support to him whatsoever. Balls pinged around his neck consistently. A good player we are wasting!
Subs: J. Clarke 6 Jakubiak 5 - poor when he came on Payne - 5 - comes across a rude boy who doesn't try. Prove me wrong.
Wimbledon 5 - no worse or better than us. We just have a better keeper. End of.
Ref 5.5 - seen worse but still crap. Pillock
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 23, 2018 21:44:27 GMT
Bonham 8
Leadbitter 6 Lockyer 7 Craig 7.5 Kelly 7
Matthews 5 Upson 7 Sercombe 6 Bennett 5
O. Clarke 6
Nichols 5
Subs: J. Clarke 6 Jakubiak 6 Payne 5
Crowd 6 Ref 7 Wimbledon 5
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 23, 2018 21:50:06 GMT
Bonham 7
Leadbitter 6.5 Lockyer 8 Craig 8 Kelly 7
Matthews 5 Upson 6 Sercombe 5 Bennett 5
O. Clarke 6
Nichols 6
Subs: J. Clarke 6 Jakubiak 5 Payne Nole
Crowd 2 Ref 5 Wimbledon 5
|
|
|
Post by noblegas on Oct 23, 2018 22:04:26 GMT
Bonham 8 Strong as ever but kicking a bit wonky.
Leadbitter 7 Some nice exchanges and solid in defence. Lockyer 7.5 solid Craig 8 MOM Gets some stick on these pages (and in the podcast)but consistently effective. Kelly 6.5 Not so good going forward.
Matthews 6 Lightweight Upson 7.5 Heavyweight Sercombe 5.5 Welterweight Bennett 5 Paperweight
O. Clarke 6.5 OK
Nichols 0 Oh god please make it end. We've all tried, god knows we have. We even call him Tommy like we've taken him to our hearts. But someone needs to quietly call time on this whole sorry business and no-one need ever mention it again. It never happened.
Subs: J. Clarke 6 Jakubiak 6 Payne 6
Crowd 3 Ref 6 Wimbledon 5
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 23, 2018 22:07:03 GMT
Bonham: 8.5. Kept us in it with two great saves in the first 20 minutes. Possibly lucky to get away with a foul when they 'scored' from a corner? Would love him to stay but suspect there is no chance of that.
Leadbitter: 7. Got forward at times in first half but had his work cut out in defending. Lockyer: 8. Really is back to hia best. Solid throughout. Craig: 9 MoM. An absolute rock at the back. Brave, headed everything. Quality performance from a proper defender. Kelly: 7. Did really well for the second goal with a pacey cross. Caught out a few times defensively. A good prospect who I hope pushes Holmes-Dennis.
Matthews: 6. Tried and has quality but gave the ball away too much for my liking. O Clarke: 6.5. Some good Lines-esque driving runs complemented a battling performance. Didn't get started until we acored though. Upson: 7.5. Best game for us yet. Battled hard and was possibly the only midfielder who performed in that first 20 mins. Sercombe: 6.5. Such an enigma. With all the criticism and presaure on the strikers, Sercs appears to have escaped any scrutiny for his own lack of goals this season. In all honesty, generally contributes little without goals but he did battle hard tonight after the first goal. Bennett: 7. Signs of his form returning and good to see him battling back to correct his mistake, which then led to our second goal.
Nichols: 7. Worked so hard in a difficult position. Starved of decent service all night but his work rate was a credit.
J Clarke: 6.5 Helped solidify the defence and a good substitution at the right time. Jakubiak: 7. This lad is raw, but there's an arrogance and at times intelligence about his game that makes me think he will be a good player. Worked hard. Payne: 5. Will the real Stefan Payne please stand up. And then jump for the ball occasionally. We've seen him play with passion and commitment but again at times lime tonight he looks a bit casual and disinterested.
Ref: 5. Lenient to say the least. The contrast with the clown on Saturday who booked people for breathing was incredible. Wombles: 6. Good 20 minutes but all belief seemed to drain from them after we scored. Like Oxford, they should struggle. DC: Got the starting line up and substitions about right. Pleased for him after the stick he has taken of late.
|
|
|
Post by james246 on Oct 23, 2018 22:15:25 GMT
Bonham 8
Leadbitter 6.5 Lockyer 8 Craig 9 Kelly 7
Matthews 4 Upson 7.5 Sercombe 5 Bennett 6
O. Clarke 6
Nichols 6
Subs: J. Clarke 7 Jakubiak 5 Payne Nole
Crowd 5 Ref 6 Wimbledon 6
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 23, 2018 22:39:28 GMT
Bonham 8 Got worried when he went down injured Leadbitter 7 defended better and we needed his pace tonight Lockyer 8 great effort against big physical players Craig 8.5 cleared one off the line, used his know how to draw free kicks and defended superbly second half. Kelly 6 i bet he's never played against that sort of opponent before, a good learning experience. Matthews 5 very hit and miss Upson 7 Always looking to get on the ball, definitely getting better but that wasn't to difficult Sercombe 5 not back to his best yet Bennett 4 not his sort of game, stood next to most of their players he looked like a boy. O. Clarke 5 better when swapped with Sercombe, spent a lot of time defending, good effort on goal but had the pace took off the shot by a half block Nichols 5 very unenviable task, on his own mostly, against big defenders but never stopped trying Subs: J. Clarke 7 Jakubiak 5 Payne nole Crowd 6 DC arguing with fans behind the dugout wasn't good to see. Ref 5 don't know how he missed the elbow on Craig Wimbledon 6 team of giants and hoof ball but so much stronger than us, a bit unlucky tonight
|
|
|
Post by Henbury Gas on Oct 24, 2018 5:36:15 GMT
Bonham 7 got to be the first signature in Jan
Leadbitter 5 looked off the pace tonight Lockyer 7 Solid Craig 8 MOTM Even more solid Kelly 5 one dimensional in his approach to attacking
Matthews 4 to lightweight and again very predictable Upson 7 had a good around game Sercombe 5 Very very poor again compared to last season Bennett 4 NO end product
O. Clarke 6 apart from the first 20 mins had a very dependable game
Nichols 7 Can't fault his work rate
Subs: J. Clarke 6 always looks in control of the situation tonight Jakubiak 4 - Time to give this boy a rest. it was a boy against some solid men tonight Payne 3 - WTF did we buy this waste of space
Crowd 5 - very depressed Ref 5 - always gave me the impression he was trying to control the game but did not have a clue Wimbledon 4 - will join us in the bottom league on this show
|
|
|
Post by z1zou on Oct 24, 2018 5:47:58 GMT
Bonham 8.5 another fantastic display
Leadbitter 6.5- looked better going forward than defensively Lockyer 7 - defensively solid, poor distribution Craig 9 motm - one of his best displays Kelly - 7.5 - needs to improve on the ball, brilliant cross led to goal
Matthews 6.5 - busy, but not effective Upson - 8 - broke up play and kept things simple Sercombe 7 - looked fitter but still not on form Bennett 5- looked out of sorts
O. Clarke 6 - lacked quality on the ball but worked tirelessly defensively
Nichols 6.5 - kept going, no service, defended valiantly from the front
Subs: J. Clarke 6 Jakubiak 5 Payne 5
Crowd 5 a very quiet mem, we need to start games on the front foot to lift the atmosphere Ref 5, got several key decisions wrong, missed a clear wombles penalty Wimbledon 4, woeful pump ball side, another team may well have stuck 4 or 5 passed us
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 24, 2018 7:04:42 GMT
Bonham 7.5 Leadbitter 5.5 Lockyer 7 Craig 8 Kelly 6 Upson 8 Bennett 4 Clarke O 5.5 Matthews 4 Sercombe 5 Nichols 6.5
Clarke J 6 Jakubiak 4 Payne nole
Crowd 6 Ref 5 Wimbledon 6
Watched on ifollow. Did not fancy a 200 mile round trip after recent performances. After seeing that glad I did! We are a poor side, Wimbledon were a better side who wasted their chances and were undone by two lucky goals. Ref missed clear penalty for them in the area and gave the freekick outside.
|
|
|
Post by Parrot on Oct 24, 2018 7:05:44 GMT
Bonham 7.5
Leadbitter 6 Lockyer 8 Craig 9 Kelly 6
Matthews 5 Upson 7 Sercombe 6 Bennett 6
O. Clarke 6
Nichols 5
Subs: J. Clarke 6 Jakubiak 5 Payne N o l e
Crowd 5 Ref 6 Wimbledon 6
DC 5
|
|
|
Post by stevek192 on Oct 24, 2018 7:51:47 GMT
Bonham 8
Leadbitter 7 Lockyer 8 Craig 9 MOM Kelly 6.5
Matthews 4 Upson 8.5 Sercombe 5 Bennett 5
O. Clarke 5.5
Nichols 6
Subs: J. Clarke 6.5 Jakubiak 4 Payne NOLE
Crowd 4 Ref 7 Wimbledon 5
DC 4
|
|
|
Post by eastville1966 on Oct 24, 2018 8:11:38 GMT
Bonham 8
Leadbitter 6 Lockyer 7 Craig 7 Kelly 7
Matthews 5 Upson 6 Sercombe 5 Bennett 5
O. Clarke 5
Nichols 6
Subs: J. Clarke 6 Jakubiak 5 Payne 5
Crowd 5 Ref 5 Wimbledon 5
|
|
|
Post by biggsy on Oct 24, 2018 8:54:12 GMT
Bonham 8 another assured display Leadbitter 6.5 an ok game, i still dont think he's up to full speed yet. Lockyer 8 defended well Craig 8,5 M.o.M he pet his body on the line for the team, an inspirational performance,his best game yet. Kelly 7 steady and efficient, a great cross which produced the second goal. Matthews 6.5 gave the ball away too much but he shows quality on the ball. A great prospect. Upson 8 always involved, worked hard. Sercombe 7 getting better, he's much better centrally. Bennett 6.5 flitted in and out, not as effective as Saturday but difficult against a team of giants. O. Clarke 7 worked hard Nichols 6 put in a decent shift but was never going to score against such a big team Subs: J. Clarke 6.5 his usual dependable self Jakubiak 6 he still has a lot to learn but did ok. Payne n.o.l.e. Crowd 6 down on numbers but big games on live tv and our general form being poor didnt help. Ref 6 average. Wimbledon 5 typical Wimbledon big strong and ugly they probably deserved a point on the night but they will struggle to stay up.
|
|
|
Post by I Voted For Kodos on Oct 24, 2018 9:28:21 GMT
My own opinions from the game:
Bonham 8 Couldn't tell if he got a touch on the shot that hit the post but made himself big to stop another just afterwards. Kicking could be questioned, but don't know who he was supposed to aim for.
Leadbitter 7 Relatively untroubled, didn't get forward much Lockyer 7 Decent game Craig 8 Decent game and always aware of the danger around him as proved with the goal-line clearance Kelly 7.5 Tried to take a few more touches on the ball than the rest of the defence and a good first time cross for the second goal
Matthews 5 Lost the ball too many times after overplaying it. Great corner though Upson 7.5 Grew into the game and took control in the midfield after we lacked that in the first twenty Sercombe 5.5 Strangely ineffectual, both when in the midfield two and when moved into the hole. Still showed energy in the final minutes he is back to full fitness if not form. Bennett 5 Didn't get on the ball often enough and didn't produce enough with it
O. Clarke 5 Absolutely lost when played in the hole and overshadowed by Upson when in the midfield two. A couple of bursting runs showed it wasn't for lack of trying
Nichols 7 Did the best he could with the little service he got. His best moment came when he won the ball and linked well with Jakubiak to create a chance
Subs: J. Clarke 7 Solidified the defence and provided a physical saw us through to the end Jakubiak 6.5 Put himself around and had a Payne 4.5 Wasn't on for long but could have at least jumped for the two headers he was up for
Crowd 4 Ref 6 card-shy but at least fairly consistent Wimbledon 5
|
|
irene
Reserve Team
Posts: 382
|
Post by irene on Oct 24, 2018 9:35:04 GMT
Bonham 8 Strong as ever but kicking a bit wonky. Leadbitter 7 Some nice exchanges and solid in defence. Lockyer 7.5 solid Craig 8 MOM Gets some stick on these pages (and in the podcast)but consistently effective. Kelly 6.5 Not so good going forward. Matthews 6 Lightweight Upson 7.5 Heavyweight Sercombe 5.5 Welterweight Bennett 5 Paperweight O. Clarke 6.5 OK Nichols 0 Oh god please make it end. We've all tried, god knows we have. We even call him Tommy like we've taken him to our hearts. But someone needs to quietly call time on this whole sorry business and no-one need ever mention it again. It never happened. Subs: J. Clarke 6 Jakubiak 6 Payne 6 Crowd 3 Ref 6 Wimbledon 5
|
|
irene
Reserve Team
Posts: 382
|
Post by irene on Oct 24, 2018 9:36:22 GMT
Ridiculous 0 Mark for Nichols for Christ’s sake give it a rest
|
|
|
Post by Gas Go Marching In on Oct 24, 2018 10:00:02 GMT
Bonham 7.5 Sign him up
Leadbitter 6.5 Decent Lockyer 7.5 Solid Craig 8 Best performance yet? Kelly 6.5 Good cross for the goal. A work in progress.
Sercombe 5.5 Not up to speed yet Upson 7 Pick of the midfield, worked hard and did well. I can't fully take to him as I feel he is a bit one paced. Is he too passive? Clarke 5.5 Not his best game
Bennett 5 A frustrating player for a manager I would imagine, brilliant on his day but didn't get on the ball enough. Maybe the physicality of Wimbledon didn't suit him on this occasion. Nichols 6.5 Isolated up front and service was water poor if truth be told. At least he tried to compete and I'd rather him than Payne from what I have seen of them both Matthews 6 Corner contributed to first goal. Gave the ball away too much but I do really like him and think that when we click, he will really come into his element. He will no doubt go for a decent amount of money in the future and I intend to enjoy him whilst he's here. Always looking to make things happen and always positive and looking forwards. Watch this space.
J Clarke 6 Solidified the defence Jakubiak 4.5 Not great Payne 4 Useless, lazy w**ker
Crowd 5 Need to lift the levels on and off the pitch Ref 6.5 More the sort of ref I like, complete contrast to Saturday's ref, let the game flow a bit more. Probably too lenient in honesty at times. Wimbledon 5 First half they were ok but I think we made them look better than they are. They will be in the relegation fight.
|
|