|
|
Post by Hugo the Elder on Oct 25, 2015 6:56:11 GMT
So your mark for Taylor is a false one by your own admission! Perhaps you will enlighten us as to your opinion of his true worth. For the record i also thought he was useless today and can confirm that he did not touch the ball at all until after the score was 1-1. His first bad miss put the nail in the coffin as heads dropped. Taylor was the second worst Rovers player today…..no agenda here just seeing things for what they are. Doesnt surprise me you agree with lover boy Bideford. You love to follow each other around on here. Bang out of order that GGMI. You've made a fool of yourself there and it undermines your argument. Shame. |
|
|
|
Post by Hugo the Elder on Oct 25, 2015 6:57:00 GMT
Nicholls - 4 bad error, looked poor today Leadbitter - 6 Good going forward but not convinced about his defending Lockyer - 6 steady but unspectacular Parkes - 1 p**s poor simples Brown - 5 good first half non existant second Gosling - 4 very average Mansell - 5 out run by a younger midfield Sinclair - 5.5 consistent but not creative Bodin - 5 apart from a brilliant goal nothing great Easter - 4 Crap today Taylor - 3 misses too many chances Lines - 5 tried to open things up but strangely out of form Montano - 4 a few flashes of ability but not much Harrison - 4 offered nothing different Crowd - 3 subdued Ref - 5 average DC - 4 got to sort out a goalscorer not sure he knows the best tactics to play at home I was at the same game as Smudge. These are also my ratings. |
|
|
|
Post by I Voted For Kodos on Oct 25, 2015 9:30:42 GMT
Okay, my views.
The idea of this thread is to aggregate opinion on players. Obviously people will have different opinions and that is what makes this thread worthwhile in my opinion. Debate on this thread about individual marks is encouraged as seeing the reasoning behind a mark is interesting. All opinions should be based on your own views and shouldn't take into account what others have already given. I try not to look at the other ratings before giving my views.
GGMI, I've defended you on other threads in the past, but you've overstepped the mark here. Personally, Bideford and GasHeadBlues are valued members of this forum, have contributed over 70 ratings between them, and I don't want to lose them from this forum. I'm going to leave it up to the mods on what, if any, action to take against you, but I feel you've broken forum rules by attacking a the poster not the post and by not letting the issue drop.
As you've admitted Taylor was in your honest opinion a 6, I'm taking that as your score.
Thanks to all other posters who have continued to contribute to this thread. Over 20 responses is the best we've ever had.
|
|
|
|
Post by Gas Go Marching In on Oct 25, 2015 10:00:24 GMT
Okay, my views. The idea of this thread is to aggregate opinion on players. Obviously people will have different opinions and that is what makes this thread worthwhile in my opinion. Debate on this thread about individual marks is encouraged as seeing the reasoning behind a mark is interesting. All opinions should be based on your own views and shouldn't take into account what others have already given. I try not to look at the other ratings before giving my views. GGMI, I've defended you on other threads in the past, but you've overstepped the mark here. Personally, Bideford and GasHeadBlues are valued members of this forum, have contributed over 70 ratings between them, and I don't want to lose them from this forum. I'm going to leave it up to the mods on what, if any, action to take against you, but I feel you've broken forum rules by attacking a the poster not the post and by not letting the issue drop. As you've admitted Taylor was in your honest opinion a 6, I'm taking that as your score. Thanks to all other posters who have continued to contribute to this thread. Over 20 responses is the best we've ever had. I understand that you don't want to lose them as they contribute regularly to the ratings but if Taylor's rating for the season is going to be wrongly too low because a few people (not forgetting tboner too) have it in for him. Also, nobody is making anyone leave. Bideford is going to ignore me, which is fair enough to be fair. Gasheadblues threatening to leave the forum over something so trivial though is not my fault and is his prerogative. |
|
|
|
Post by I Voted For Kodos on Oct 25, 2015 10:18:55 GMT
Okay, my views. The idea of this thread is to aggregate opinion on players. Obviously people will have different opinions and that is what makes this thread worthwhile in my opinion. Debate on this thread about individual marks is encouraged as seeing the reasoning behind a mark is interesting. All opinions should be based on your own views and shouldn't take into account what others have already given. I try not to look at the other ratings before giving my views. GGMI, I've defended you on other threads in the past, but you've overstepped the mark here. Personally, Bideford and GasHeadBlues are valued members of this forum, have contributed over 70 ratings between them, and I don't want to lose them from this forum. I'm going to leave it up to the mods on what, if any, action to take against you, but I feel you've broken forum rules by attacking a the poster not the post and by not letting the issue drop. As you've admitted Taylor was in your honest opinion a 6, I'm taking that as your score. Thanks to all other posters who have continued to contribute to this thread. Over 20 responses is the best we've ever had. I understand that you don't want to lose them as they contribute regularly to the ratings but if Taylor's rating for the season is going to be wrongly too low because a few people (not forgetting tboner too) have it in for him. Also, nobody is making anyone leave. Bideford is going to ignore me, which is fair enough to be fair. Gasheadblues threatening to leave the forum over something so trivial though is not my fault and is his prerogative. But the problem is that this is only your opinion that its too low. People's opinions are what they are and you can't be trying to correct that with your own ratings. Also, these ratings are mainly a bit of fun and I think you're placing too much worth on them. Everything on this forum has to be taken with a dose of reality. Its not as if Clarke is going to sell Taylor at the end of the season based on his season rating. On your second point, yes the original argument was trivial, but you then made it personal. You're right, nobody is making them leave, but you aren't giving them any reason to want to stay on this forum if you keep going after their posts. |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 25, 2015 14:54:29 GMT
Nicholls 1 looked like a rabbit in the headlight and not much better on tuesdasy
Leadbitter 8 Head and shoulders above the rest
Lockyer 5 Lost his way and his opponent numerous times leaving Parkes 2 on 1
Parkes 3 A long way off his best,what has happened behind the scenes to cause this
Brown 6 Our only other threat
Bodin 5 Scored a cracker then disappeared
Sinclair 5 Very poor game seemed to think he had to be everywhere and finished up nowhere
Mansell 3 Innocous throughout the game
Gosling 4 As Bodin without the goal
Easter 5 Worked hard and at his age shouldn't be the 1 chasing the defenders
Taylor 2 What can I say
Lines 6 at least he tried ti instyigate some action but brought on far too late
Montana 4 NOt up to league standard
Harrison 5 Tried to get some positivity out of the game but it was too late by the time he came on
DC 3 TActics all over the place,substitutions far too late to have any impact on the game
and why long balls forward to 2 midgets
Ref 96 had a reasonable game nothing contentious and tried to let it flow
John Sheridan 8 showed how a man who has played at a high level can out wit one who hasnt
|
|
|
|
Post by lpgas on Oct 25, 2015 15:46:19 GMT
Nicholls 1 Didn't have a lot to do but what he did do was poor
Leadbitter 4 Did well considering
Lockyer 6 Probably the man of the match
Parkes 1 Looked like he was playing after a night on the water
Brown 4 Below average
Bodin 6 has to take a credit for the goal and some good play
Mansell 3 Too slow, players passed him like he wasn't there
Sinclair 3 frustrating! Often out of position leaving holes in midfield. And all those passes sideways or back. Lacks vision
Gosling 2 Still non league. Not good enough
Taylor 4 Got in to lots of good positions but very few quality balls from midfield to him
Easter 3 Wish I had a £1 for every time he fell over
Subs: 6 Lines Should have been on from the start
Montano: 5 Cannot understand ho Gosling gets chosen in front of him
Harrison: 2 Waste of time himcoming on
Crowd 4 Understandable
Ref 6 OK
Newport 8 Had done their homework against a predictable Rovers home game
|
|
|
|
Post by Gas Go Marching In on Oct 25, 2015 16:31:55 GMT
I Voted For Kodos I would like to make an official apology for messing about with the ratings. I did feel it had to be done but was unfair to mess you around with the ratings in the process, especially seeing as you put so much effort into them.
|
|
|
|
Post by nailseamark on Oct 25, 2015 21:22:31 GMT
Nichols 2- an absolute shocker and the bloke is also just easy to dislike. Helped wasting my 20 pounds with a mistake that a toddler wouldn't commit.
Leadbitter 7- did okay, got forward and put lots of crosses in....nobody met them but they could of!
Lockyer 6- Usual performance Mr Reliable
Parkes 1- He just doesn't look like a pro footballer. His face has gotten so fat that he looks more like a professional pie eater.
To blame for 2 goals and his passing was woefull too. Drop him so hard it might knock that fat off.
Brown 5- Didnt really see him, so can't of been too bad.
Gosling 3 - Just not very good. Seems terrified of playing at home.
Mansell 4- completely over run in midfield and just not up to it. Also just plain boring.
Sinclair 5- the worst game I've seen him play for us. He just didn't seem his normal battling self today. Would of been a lower mark but he was pretty good in the first half.
Bodin 5- scored a screamer. Then spent the rest of the game putting me to sleep. I just can't get on board with him.
Easter 5- Only remember him having one shot and it sucked.
Taylor 5- created lots of chances. Had about 20 shots....they all sucked.
Montano 4- The most pointless player in rovers history.
Harrison 3- His performances recently are starting to grind my gears and this one in particular left me feeling quite sick. He just doesn't care any more.
Lines 5- Dont remember him doing anything except look completely miserable.
Crowd 2- just boring and it doesn't feel like anybody wants to be there. All the fun, energetic people have been banned and we're left with mostly miserable old men.
Ref 8- Thought he was pretty much spot on to be honest.
Dc 4- didn't really have enough players to make changes and we did okay first half so I will give him a passin this game.
|
|
|
|
Post by I Voted For Kodos on Oct 25, 2015 21:32:01 GMT
I Voted For Kodos I would like to make an official apology for messing about with the ratings. I did feel it had to be done but was unfair to mess you around with the ratings in the process, especially seeing as you put so much effort into them. I appreciate it, but I don't feel its me that you owe an apology to. |
|
|
|
Post by I Voted For Kodos on Oct 25, 2015 21:32:50 GMT
Right lets get on with the actual ratings.
Daniel Leadbitter was MotM with a score of 6.5, the second lowest MotM score of the season, after James Clarke in the opening game.
The starting XI average of 4.63 was also the lowest score since the opening game. Obviously this was mainly due to the low scores of Parkes and Nicholls.
Parkes' 1.67 was the lowest rating of the season. Last year the lowest was also 1.67, both Parkes and McChrystal at Alfreton.
Edit: with Henbury's marks below, Parkes' rating drops to 1.64. He now solely holds the lowest score and McChrystal loses an unwanted record.
Nicholls' 2.7 was the lowest by any keeper in the Player Ratings threads. Fabian Spiess previously held the record with his 3.1 at Torquay.
Leadbitter's MotM score was 1.9 above the team average, the biggest difference of the season. The previous best was Lockyer being 1.7 points above the team average against Portsmouth.
Finally, 25 ratings was the highest number ever on this thread, beating the 21 who rated the Play-off final last year.
Nicholls 2.7
Leadbitter 6.5
Lockyer 5.7
Parkes 1.6
Brown 5.3
Bodin 5.5
Mansell 5.1
Sinclair 5.0
Gosling 4.9
Taylor 3.6
Easter 4.7
Subs: Lines 4.8
Montano 4.3
Harrison 3.8
Crowd 4.0
Ref 5.8
Newport 5.6
With these bad ratings its a shame we can't see the old Player Ratings threads run by Bright Side of Life on the OF. It would be interesting to compare some of the individual scores and team averages from that period.
|
|
|
|
Post by Henbury Gas on Oct 26, 2015 8:08:25 GMT
Nicholls 5 got the jitters because of the clown in front of him but ok
Leadbitter 6 Pick if the bunch going forward defending getting better
Lockyer 6 Trying to cover for 2 people did ok against a good strike force
Parkes 1 gave him 1 for getting to the ground on time - shocking and has been all season
Brown 5 Up against a good winger and got found out a couple of times
Bodin 5 scored and did little else of note
Mansell 5 Normal mans kick and hope stye football
Sinclair 2 Teams know how to play him now maybe time to drop for a while
Gosling 6 good first half but lost interest after that
Taylor 6 Best striker at the club unlucky with some of his efforts
Easter 1 Same as parkes - time to drop me thinks
Subs: Lines 3 did he do anything of note ?
Montano 3 could have /should have scored
Harrison 3 forgot he came on.....
Crowd 4 very quite
Ref 5 as good as any
Newport 7 wish we had their strike force
|
|
|
|
Post by stigofthegas on Oct 26, 2015 11:57:16 GMT
Right lets get on with the actual ratings. Daniel Leadbitter was MotM with a score of 6.6, the second lowest MotM score of the season, after James Clarke in the opening game. The starting XI average of 4.63 was also the lowest score since the opening game. Obviously this was mainly due to the low scores of Parkes and Nicholls. Parkes' 1.67 was the lowest rating of the season. Last year the lowest was also 1.67, both Parkes and McChrystal at Alfreton. Edit: with Henbury's marks below, Parkes' rating drops to 1.64. He now solely holds the lowest score and McChrystal loses an unwanted record.Nicholls' 2.6 was the lowest by any keeper in the Player Ratings threads. Fabian Spiess previously held the record with his 3.1 at Torquay. Leadbitter's MotM score was 1.9 above the team average, the biggest difference of the season. The previous best was Lockyer being 1.7 points above the team average against Portsmouth. Finally, 24 ratings was the highest number ever on this thread, beating the 21 who rated the Play-off final last year. Nicholls 2.6 Leadbitter 6.6Lockyer 5.7 Parkes 1.6 Brown 5.3 Bodin 5.5 Mansell 5.1 Sinclair 5.1 Gosling 4.8 Taylor 3.5 Easter 4.9 Subs: Lines 4.9 Montano 4.4 Harrison 3.8 Crowd 4.0 Ref 5.9 Newport 5.6 With these bad ratings its a shame we can't see the old Player Ratings threads run by Bright Side of Life on the OF. It would be interesting to compare some of the individual scores and team averages from that period. Top work again Unigas - keep it up mate and dont let the nonsense grind you down. Stat that stands out for me is the ref's score. The ref has the second highest score, I bet that doesnt happen very often. |
|
|
|
Post by I Voted For Kodos on Oct 26, 2015 21:01:42 GMT
Top work again Unigas - keep it up mate and dont let the nonsense grind you down. Stat that stands out for me is the ref's score. The ref has the second highest score, I bet that doesnt happen very often. It looks like it has happened 5 times last season ( Grimsby home, FGR away, Alfreton away, Welling home and Nuneaton away) and once this season (Portsmouth home). The ones in bold were games when the referee got the highest score. |
|
|
|
Post by stigofthegas on Oct 26, 2015 21:30:38 GMT
Top work again Unigas - keep it up mate and dont let the nonsense grind you down. Stat that stands out for me is the ref's score. The ref has the second highest score, I bet that doesnt happen very often. It looks like it has happened 5 times last season ( Grimsby home, FGR away, Alfreton away, Welling home and Nuneaton away) and once this season (Portsmouth home). The ones in bold were games when the referee got the highest score. Wow, I'm surprised. I guess that shows that we are pretty fair on the refs overall. |
|
