|
Post by oldgas on Mar 31, 2019 9:23:06 GMT
What I have noticed is that when TN is substituted after another inept performance where he has been routinely muscled off the ball, is the massive love-in he receives from GC.
I'm all in favour of giving players encouragement, but come on!
This is a player who has scored 2? League goals this season. He shouldn't be starting.
|
|
|
Post by lisbongas on Mar 31, 2019 9:27:52 GMT
What I have noticed is that when TN is substituted after another inept performance where he has been routinely muscled off the ball, is the massive love-in he receives from GC. I'm all in favour of giving players encouragement, but come on! This is a player who has scored 2? League goals this season. He shouldn't be starting. What are the other options, Jakubiak and Reilly are even worse
|
|
|
Post by Gassy on Mar 31, 2019 9:39:55 GMT
What I have noticed is that when TN is substituted after another inept performance where he has been routinely muscled off the ball, is the massive love-in he receives from GC. I'm all in favour of giving players encouragement, but come on! This is a player who has scored 2? League goals this season. He shouldn't be starting. What are the other options, Jakubiak and Reilly are even worse Harsh as the only time they've really had to play with JCH was in an awful 433 formation, where JCH hardly shone himself. I rate Jakubiak but he's not an assister as Nichols is. Reilly is more similar to Nichols & has much better finishing. The most frustrating thing from Nichols at times is he just won't pass the ball as much as he should. Recently he's been taking the extra 'turn' or trying to take on the extra player and ends up getting tackled, breaking down the counter attack/move. Jakubiak will go in the summer back to Watford, I reckon Nichols is out of contract too. Clearly GC has an eye for a good striker at this level, so he'll, have his work cut out for him needing to sign 2 more
|
|
|
Post by oldgas on Mar 31, 2019 10:45:53 GMT
I don't think Jak is the answer and we shouldn't try and keep him beyond his loan.. Reilly is worth persevering with and I feel that even if Nicholls is still under contract we should cut our losses and let him go. He always tries hard, has some decent touches and passing ability, but he just never looks like scoring. I have wanted so much for him to come good, but he just can't do what he's here for. Sometimes it just doesn't work out I'm sure he would leave with genuine best wishes from the fans.
In his post match GC stated he knew exactly what he wanted for next season. When pressed on this he quite rightly refuses to elaborate but I'm hopeful he does know exactly who we need and, provided we stay up, the board must support him in this. You can stay up by the skin of your teeth for one season, but to leave us in a perilous position for next season would invite, almost guarantee disaster.
Having got to League 1 we mustn't relinquish it, I've said on many occasions that because of the foreign talent in the Prem and Championship, this is at least the equivalent of the old Football League Division 2, and we should strive to make this our base line position. Anything higher will, I'm afraid, require a new stadium and monied owners. Not a distant foreign banking family who at the moment seem more interested in fighting amongst each other whilst the club slip slowly away.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 31, 2019 10:59:25 GMT
I don't think Jak is the answer and we shouldn't try and keep him beyond his loan.. Reilly is worth persevering with and I feel that even if Nicholls is still under contract we should cut our losses and let him go. He always tries hard, has some decent touches and passing ability, but he just never looks like scoring. I have wanted so much for him to come good, but he just can't do what he's here for. Sometimes it just doesn't work out I'm sure he would leave with genuine best wishes from the fans. In his post match GC stated he knew exactly what he wanted for next season. When pressed on this he quite rightly refuses to elaborate but I'm hopeful he does know exactly who we need and, provided we stay up, the board must support him in this. You can stay up by the skin of your teeth for one season, but to leave us in a perilous position for next season would invite, almost guarantee disaster. Having got to League 1 we mustn't relinquish it, I've said on many occasions that because of the foreign talent in the Prem and Championship, this is at least the equivalent of the old Football League Division 2, and we should strive to make this our base line position. Anything higher will, I'm afraid, require a new stadium and monied owners. Not a distant foreign banking family who at the moment seem more interested in fighting amongst each other whilst the club slip slowly away. Agree with all of that mate ... spot on.
|
|
|
Post by Congas on Mar 31, 2019 11:13:00 GMT
What I have noticed is that when TN is substituted after another inept performance where he has been routinely muscled off the ball, is the massive love-in he receives from GC. I'm all in favour of giving players encouragement, but come on! This is a player who has scored 2? League goals this season. He shouldn't be starting. What are the other options, Jakubiak and Reilly are even worse They're not worse, but they're certainly no better. All three of them run into patrols as soon as they start trying to dribble their way through. I'd give Reilly another season because he has the knack of getting goals in the box and keeps a cool head in one-on-ones with the keeper. He's been played too deep I think. JCH can't always get us out of trouble with his wonder goals. He needs a partner who reads his game and who can chip in with 10 or so goals a season. Also, our midfield lacks creativity. It seems as though people think we'll get enough points from our games against bottom clubs. Well, Wimbledon seem to be on an upward surge and won't be easy on their own patch so I wouldn't count our chickens there. We need at least a draw at Coventry, who've got nothing to play for really.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 31, 2019 11:27:06 GMT
I Accept GC has delivered results that have kept us in with a chance and in most other seasons the opposition below us would have collapsed. However the football is dross and performance of the majority woeful. Some of the worse performances seen for many a year. I am not conviced by GC and his motivational ability or tactical nounce. We are now simply being carried by a centreforward plucked from Coventry reserves with a point to prove. JCH has almost singlehandedly saved the day, what a star. A few others are digging in, notably Craig and Lockyer, Ogogo and Bonham (bar Doncaster) beyond this not much fight being shown. The buck stops with GC. I recognise I am out of kilter with the majority on this forum as again yesterday I watch a game where James Clarke is beaten at will, rarely cuts out a cross, loses his man on the first goal and yet he is voted our best defender. Nicholls was not good he seems to have dropped back a level but Jakubiak and Reilly are not good enough at this level perhaps push Sercombe up top? If lines is fit he may be worth a shout but can GC get the best out of him, i doubt it. Great player but needs to be managed to get him playing in a positive way. Do we have fullbacks that can attack and offer width but also defend. TDH was outstanding against Sunderland but poor at Doncaster, Partington or Leadbetter. Perhaps away play 5 at the back and push the fullbacks on. Juat a few games for someone to step up and be a hero. JCH cannot be our only hope. Not sure it matters where JCH was "plucked from" the simple fact is he has proven to be an amazing signing by GC despite all the criticism the day he was announced. James Clarke has been one of our best and most consistent this season players this season and is also one of the most committed players every time he wears the shirt. GC has been getting good results since taking charge and if that continues we'll be ok. Making experimental changes like putting Sercombe up front would be complete madness at this stage. DC and GC we're criticised for playing him on the left but I think his performances from there have been better than when he has played in his preferred central position behind the strikers.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 31, 2019 11:30:39 GMT
What I have noticed is that when TN is substituted after another inept performance where he has been routinely muscled off the ball, is the massive love-in he receives from GC. I'm all in favour of giving players encouragement, but come on! This is a player who has scored 2? League goals this season. He shouldn't be starting. Is that not good man management? If Nichols is a confidence player and reacts better to that then what is the problem? GC knows the players personalities and what they best respond to. Would you prefer he gave him a public rollicking and clip round the ear as he came off?
|
|
|
Post by baggins on Mar 31, 2019 11:50:25 GMT
Considering where they are and the results they've earnt I don't think we did too bad to be honest. Apart from their 2 goals, Bonham wasn't troubled all game.
|
|
|
Post by rosssgb on Mar 31, 2019 14:04:37 GMT
What I have noticed is that when TN is substituted after another inept performance where he has been routinely muscled off the ball, is the massive love-in he receives from GC. I'm all in favour of giving players encouragement, but come on! This is a player who has scored 2? League goals this season. He shouldn't be starting. Usually Nichols creates a few opportunities and is involved in the link up play, yesterday against better quality opposition he was abysmal. Not sure how people can continue to have faith in him coming good. For me if we continue with this formation we have to try him in Sercombe’s position. In a relegation battle you can’t persist with a striker who doesn’t look like scoring, Jak and JHC have to be first choice with Reilly off the bench.
|
|
|
Post by baggins on Mar 31, 2019 14:08:38 GMT
What I have noticed is that when TN is substituted after another inept performance where he has been routinely muscled off the ball, is the massive love-in he receives from GC. I'm all in favour of giving players encouragement, but come on! This is a player who has scored 2? League goals this season. He shouldn't be starting. Usually Nichols creates a few opportunities and is involved in the link up play, yesterday against better quality opposition he was abysmal. Not sure how people can continue to have faith in him coming good. For me if we continue with this formation we have to try him in Sercombe’s position. In a relegation battle you can’t persist with a striker who doesn’t look like scoring, Jak and JHC have to be first choice with Reilly off the bench. You say that, but when Jak came on as sub yesterday, he did nothing. Nothing at all. In fact, I'd be surprised if he even touched the ball.
|
|
|
Post by neilv93 on Mar 31, 2019 14:47:38 GMT
Usually Nichols creates a few opportunities and is involved in the link up play, yesterday against better quality opposition he was abysmal. Not sure how people can continue to have faith in him coming good. For me if we continue with this formation we have to try him in Sercombe’s position. In a relegation battle you can’t persist with a striker who doesn’t look like scoring, Jak and JHC have to be first choice with Reilly off the bench. You say that, but when Jak came on as sub yesterday, he did nothing. Nothing at all. In fact, I'd be surprised if he even touched the ball. Agreed. If we're persisting with the diamond next season then I'd like to see Nichols in the hole (Sercombe likely off anyway) and upgrades on Jak (who will go back to Watford) and Reilly (decent back up option). A Matty Taylor-esque striker alongside JCH would be perfect - running onto knock-downs, fox in the box, pitbull on defenders all game... I digress.
|
|
|
Post by CrispPusher on Mar 31, 2019 15:13:24 GMT
Tom Nichols has 1 league goal (a penalty) and 7 assists in 39 appearances, combined that's involved in 8 goals. That's fewer than Jonson Clarke-Harris has scored in 11 appearances, it's little wonder we are where we are in the table playing "strikers" like Nichols week in week out 😂
|
|
|
Post by oldgas on Apr 1, 2019 5:10:19 GMT
What I have noticed is that when TN is substituted after another inept performance where he has been routinely muscled off the ball, is the massive love-in he receives from GC. I'm all in favour of giving players encouragement, but come on! This is a player who has scored 2? League goals this season. He shouldn't be starting. Is that not good man management? If Nichols is a confidence player and reacts better to that then what is the problem? GC knows the players personalities and what they best respond to. Would you prefer he gave him a public rollicking and clip round the ear as he came off? I agree it's good man-management, but I wonder whether instead of having to give him a big love-in following a fairly inept performance, it might serve him better if he sat out a few games. Its difficult, who'd be a manager?
|
|
|
Post by lisbongas on Apr 1, 2019 12:17:41 GMT
Tom Nichols has 1 league goal (a penalty) and 7 assists in 39 appearances, combined that's involved in 8 goals. That's fewer than Jonson Clarke-Harris has scored in 11 appearances, it's little wonder we are where we are in the table playing "strikers" like Nichols week in week out 😂 Who else do you play, the alternatives do even less.
|
|
|
Post by Topper Gas on Apr 1, 2019 12:24:47 GMT
Tom Nichols has 1 league goal (a penalty) and 7 assists in 39 appearances, combined that's involved in 8 goals. That's fewer than Jonson Clarke-Harris has scored in 11 appearances, it's little wonder we are where we are in the table playing "strikers" like Nichols week in week out 😂 Who else do you play, the alternatives do even less. How many times have one of this asked the same question but posters moaning about TN can never answer the question? You'd think after the shocker at Donny w/o TN posters would let it rest until the end of the season. If we're still in Div 1 next season it will be interesting to see how we line up for our first league game.
|
|
|
Post by neilv93 on Apr 1, 2019 14:32:16 GMT
Who else do you play, the alternatives do even less. How many times have one of this asked the same question but posters moaning about TN can never answer the question? You'd think after the shocker at Donny w/o TN posters would let it rest until the end of the season. If we're still in Div 1 next season it will be interesting to see how we line up for our first league game. I think Tom will still be here come 19/20 season kick-off. GC rates him, always encourages him, publicly stated he didn't want him to go in January and like it or not, he has largely performed well under GC (although I'll admit he's been poor in the last few games). I reckon at worst he's a squad player for us next season but confident he'll still be here one way or the other.
|
|
|
Post by Topper Gas on Apr 1, 2019 15:33:09 GMT
How many times have one of this asked the same question but posters moaning about TN can never answer the question? You'd think after the shocker at Donny w/o TN posters would let it rest until the end of the season. If we're still in Div 1 next season it will be interesting to see how we line up for our first league game. I think Tom will still be here come 19/20 season kick-off. GC rates him, always encourages him, publicly stated he didn't want him to go in January and like it or not, he has largely performed well under GC (although I'll admit he's been poor in the last few games). I reckon at worst he's a squad player for us next season but confident he'll still be here one way or the other. Not sure saying if he doesn't score goals he'll be off in the summer would be good player management!! let's be honest wecan;t survive another season in Div 1 with non scoring No 10's.
|
|