|
Post by stuartcampbell on Jun 9, 2020 19:53:08 GMT
To pick out Normandy for instance, there were 156,000 soldiers during the Normandy landings, the vast majority of which were not British. Vast majority? Also, how did they get there? Swim the while width of the channel? Yes, 39.5% were British. And goodness gracious, I wonder how the US were able to develop the nuclear bomb, given we were clearly the only country to have invented boats!
|
|
|
Post by trevorgas on Jun 9, 2020 20:04:19 GMT
First couple of sentences are wrong too. Anyone can open up a history book and find out that the vast majority of Germany's expansion throughout the war was done pre-USSR involvement, and although it's true that Germany were initially winning their battle against the USSR the overall balance of the war changed during the Battle of Stalingrad. And who was supplying the Russians via the horrendous Artic Convoys,so as we didn't do much in Normandy and crossing the Rhine who was landing at Arnhem and battling the Germans at Monte Cassino whilst fighting the Japanese to a standstill at Kohima Ridge?
|
|
|
Post by Big Jock on Jun 9, 2020 20:17:55 GMT
I actually think th felling of Edward Colston may go on to be a catalytic moment in history where the world progressed just that little bit more.
Was it wrong/unlawful how it happened - absolutely. but th bigger picture is Wow, it happened and it was history bein written an in th place we care about. don't under estimate it folks those scenes will be shown for years, an hopefully with Colston's statue put up in a museum it will educate how this man made his money, gave so much to charity but ultimately hundreds of years later was brought down by folk and whose legacy will be taught to kids as a man shown for what he really was. Historians can argue whether he was good/bad/something inbetween but his history will now be highlighted by his downfall on Sunday.
May we all learn and may life be better in a tiny way because of it.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 9, 2020 20:21:35 GMT
Right let’s flip it around Oldie, we know by now what you don’t like about Britain. Quite a lot, it seems. What DO you like about the U.K.? Say something positive about it, because I have no idea what you are likely to come up with... I know this wasn't directed at Oldie but I think I might answer too. It's more cultural things for me! I like Britain's food and delacies, fish and chips, English Breakfasts, sunday roast and so on. But as it's been one of my personal favourite exercises in my life I would say personally, Britain's music to me is always something that stands out about things I love about this country. The Beatles, Led Zeppelin, Pink Floyd, Joy Division etc to more punk-orientated bands like the Clash and the Sex Pistols who are very politics-orientated lyrics wise. At least someone on this thread likes Britain 😂
|
|
|
Post by warehamgas on Jun 9, 2020 20:22:26 GMT
I actually think th felling of Edward Colston may go on to be a catalytic moment in history where the world progressed just that little bit more. Was it wrong/unlawful how it happened - absolutely. but th bigger picture is Wow, it happened and it was history bein written an in th place we care about. don't under estimate it folks those scenes will be shown for years, an hopefully with Colston's statue put up in a museum it will educate how this man made his money, gave so much to charity but ultimately hundreds of years later was brought down by folk and whose legacy will be taught to kids as a man shown for what he really was. Historians can argue whether he was good/bad/something inbetween but his history will now be highlighted by his downfall on Sunday. May we all learn and may life be better in a tiny way because of it. That’s got to be the hope BJ. UTG!
|
|
|
Post by trevorgas on Jun 9, 2020 20:23:26 GMT
I know this wasn't directed at Oldie but I think I might answer too. It's more cultural things for me! I like Britain's food and delacies, fish and chips, English Breakfasts, sunday roast and so on. But as it's been one of my personal favourite exercises in my life I would say personally, Britain's music to me is always something that stands out about things I love about this country. The Beatles, Led Zeppelin, Pink Floyd, Joy Division etc to more punk-orientated bands like the Clash and the Sex Pistols who are very politics-orientated lyrics wise. At least someone on this thread likes Britain 😂
|
|
|
Post by trevorgas on Jun 9, 2020 20:23:58 GMT
I know this wasn't directed at Oldie but I think I might answer too. It's more cultural things for me! I like Britain's food and delacies, fish and chips, English Breakfasts, sunday roast and so on. But as it's been one of my personal favourite exercises in my life I would say personally, Britain's music to me is always something that stands out about things I love about this country. The Beatles, Led Zeppelin, Pink Floyd, Joy Division etc to more punk-orientated bands like the Clash and the Sex Pistols who are very politics-orientated lyrics wise. At least someone on this thread likes Britain 😂 I do 😆😆
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 9, 2020 20:24:00 GMT
I actually think th felling of Edward Colston may go on to be a catalytic moment in history where the world progressed just that little bit more. Was it wrong/unlawful how it happened - absolutely. but th bigger picture is Wow, it happened and it was history bein written an in th place we care about. don't under estimate it folks those scenes will be shown for years, an hopefully with Colston's statue put up in a museum it will educate how this man made his money, gave so much to charity but ultimately hundreds of years later was brought down by folk and whose legacy will be taught to kids as a man shown for what he really was. Historians can argue whether he was good/bad/something inbetween but his history will now be highlighted by his downfall on Sunday. May we all learn and may life be better in a tiny way because of it. In isolation I could kind of agree- but where does it end Jock? Colston’s statue won’t be the last. Nelson’s column will be in the firing line at some point
|
|
|
Post by Rod1883 on Jun 9, 2020 20:29:10 GMT
We've drifted a little now but on D Day the British and Canadians landed over 75000 troops, the Americans 57500. We also had nearly 8000 British paratroopers dropped from the air and the Americans 15500. To say the vast majority were not British is to insult their memory. There were also ~196000 Naval personnel (my Father being one) and I don't have the figures but would expect the majority to be British.
In 1940 this country, along with the Commonwealth, stood alone with what at the time must have seemed to be little hope. Had we capitulated then I am convinced History would be very different. When the Germans went East after cancelling their pact with Russia, the Artic convoys supplied vital goods to the ports of Murmansk and Archangel. These convoys also prevented the Germans forcing a another front to attack Russia via the North of Norway. My Father served on the convoys his ship being sunk whilst protecting one of those convoys. That ship - HMS Hardy - can be seen as my avatar.
|
|
|
Post by trevorgas on Jun 9, 2020 20:36:22 GMT
We've drifted a little now but on D Day the British and Canadians landed over 75000 troops, the Americans 57500. We also had nearly 8000 British paratroopers dropped from the air and the Americans 15500. To say the vast majority were not British is to insult their memory. There were also ~196000 Naval personnel (my Father being one) and I don't have the figures but would expect the majority to be British. In 1940 this country, along with the Commonwealth, stood alone with what at the time must have seemed to be little hope. Had we capitulated then I am convinced History would be very different. When the Germans went East after cancelling their pact with Russia, the Artic convoys supplied vital goods to the ports of Murmansk and Archangel. These convoys also prevented the Germans forcing a another front to attack Russia via the North of Norway. My Father served on the convoys his ship being sunk whilst protecting one of those convoys. That ship - HMS Hardy - can be seen as my avatar. And as I have said before my Father was a 19 yr old RN medic on the beach at Omaha and it pees me off greatly when folk are so sloppy with their comments reinterpreting facts,it's to close to home for me.
|
|
|
Post by Big Jock on Jun 9, 2020 20:39:14 GMT
I actually think th felling of Edward Colston may go on to be a catalytic moment in history where the world progressed just that little bit more. Was it wrong/unlawful how it happened - absolutely. but th bigger picture is Wow, it happened and it was history bein written an in th place we care about. don't under estimate it folks those scenes will be shown for years, an hopefully with Colston's statue put up in a museum it will educate how this man made his money, gave so much to charity but ultimately hundreds of years later was brought down by folk and whose legacy will be taught to kids as a man shown for what he really was. Historians can argue whether he was good/bad/something inbetween but his history will now be highlighted by his downfall on Sunday. May we all learn and may life be better in a tiny way because of it. In isolation I could kind of agree- but where does it end Jock? Colston’s statue won’t be the last. Nelson’s column will be in the firing line at some point Hopefully not pal, but maybe a few statues are overdue removal.
I'm just sayin every now an then something happens at th right time, th right place that people take notice of, an not just you, me an the world watchin, its not ignored - its noticed, folk sit up and listen. Every now an then th public, th media, th big guns, th money men, the politicians, th powers that be sit up an listen simultaneously and maybe, just maybe th world is a better place for it.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 9, 2020 20:45:14 GMT
In isolation I could kind of agree- but where does it end Jock? Colston’s statue won’t be the last. Nelson’s column will be in the firing line at some point Hopefully not pal, but maybe a few statues are overdue removal.
I'm just sayin every now an then something happens at th right time, th right place that people take notice of, an not just you, me an the world watchin, its not ignored - its noticed, folk sit up and listen. Every now an then th public, th media, th big guns, th money men, the politicians, th powers that be sit up an listen simultaneously and maybe, just maybe th world is a better place for it.
I agree. I disagree with the protests because of the timing, I agree with the cause. As said upthread this smells like a bandwagon at the moment. Let’s see how many people fully commit and how many are willing to give up some of their own material “privilege” to improve the lives of minorities. Personal sacrifice is when it becomes all too real for the bandwagoners.
|
|
|
Post by stuart1974 on Jun 9, 2020 20:48:17 GMT
Vast majority? Also, how did they get there? Swim the while width of the channel? Yes, 39.5% were British. And goodness gracious, I wonder how the US were able to develop the nuclear bomb, given we were clearly the only country to have invented boats! I was referring to the 138,000 Royal Navy and Merchant Seamen piloting the ships, including the landing craft taking Americans ashore. That was around 3/4s of the naval forces. Hate to be blunt, but where did you learn your WWII history? edited to add, of those 156,000 there were 73,000 US forces with 61,000 British and 22,000 other allies (more non Americans landed than not using your rationale) and 2/3rds of the aircraft were British.
|
|
|
Post by stuart1974 on Jun 9, 2020 20:53:40 GMT
First couple of sentences are wrong too. Anyone can open up a history book and find out that the vast majority of Germany's expansion throughout the war was done pre-USSR involvement, and although it's true that Germany were initially winning their battle against the USSR the overall balance of the war changed during the Battle of Stalingrad. Didn't the USSR begin the war in 1939 helping to carve up Poland, the Baltics and try it on Finland?
|
|
|
Post by trevorgas on Jun 9, 2020 20:56:28 GMT
Anyone can open up a history book and find out that the vast majority of Germany's expansion throughout the war was done pre-USSR involvement, and although it's true that Germany were initially winning their battle against the USSR the overall balance of the war changed during the Battle of Stalingrad. Didn't the USSR begin the war in 1939 helping to carve up Poland, the Baltics and try it on Finland? Correct and murdering 4000 Polish Officers in cold blood.
|
|
|
Post by warehamgas on Jun 9, 2020 21:01:54 GMT
No. It’s certainly not a fact and therefore not safe to say. It’s merely your opinion which you are entitled to. The Russian-German pact from 1939-41 allowed Germany to overrun Europe and any British or Europeans killed in that time were due to the fact that Hitler was only fighting on one front, hence his ability to do what he did in that time. And I don’t think Stalin is “idolised” now, since the 70s there’s been a big revision in opinion about him. Perhaps it’s more to the idea of in this country we do have “free” speech whereas in Russia for much of the time since 1945 “free” speech was not allowed. UTG! And the tide of the war dramatically changed after the USSR entered it. Same with America. I've always seen our involvement in the overall ending of the war as that of Olivier Giroud in France's 2018 World Cup Win. And no I wasn't saying Stalin is idolised, I was saying Churchill was. Stalin is publicly tarnished. Yes it did change when Russia entered the war and that was my point, with two fronts to fight on the war was turning. Had the pact not existed form 39-41 then those years may have been different with Russia being ready to the east. Have to disagree with your comparison with OG. Pretty sure Churchill wasn’t idolised, blimey, he lost the General Election weeks later. But, overall WC was a man with faults and prejudices who today would have been very divisive but as a man for the moment he led this country when we were on our own. And, whilst we will never know for certain, I think that were it not for him we would have been speaking German now and having this conversation in German. He was a man for his time. Basically we would have been b******* without him at that time. UTG!
|
|
|
Post by stuartcampbell on Jun 9, 2020 22:56:25 GMT
We've drifted a little now but on D Day the British and Canadians landed over 75000 troops, the Americans 57500. We also had nearly 8000 British paratroopers dropped from the air and the Americans 15500. To say the vast majority were not British is to insult their memory. There were also ~196000 Naval personnel (my Father being one) and I don't have the figures but would expect the majority to be British. In 1940 this country, along with the Commonwealth, stood alone with what at the time must have seemed to be little hope. Had we capitulated then I am convinced History would be very different. When the Germans went East after cancelling their pact with Russia, the Artic convoys supplied vital goods to the ports of Murmansk and Archangel. These convoys also prevented the Germans forcing a another front to attack Russia via the North of Norway. My Father served on the convoys his ship being sunk whilst protecting one of those convoys. That ship - HMS Hardy - can be seen as my avatar. Given it assumes these are just estimates my numbers differ. I have Americans at 73k (23k at Utah Beach, 34k Omaha Beach, 15k airborne) with Britain at 61k and Canada at 21k. I didn't account for the navy personnel though, 52k American, 112k British, other 4k from various Allied countries. But we did almost capitulate, that's the thing. People love to point out Neville Chamberlain being a coward almost and resigning in place of Churchill who had the bollocks to defend. But Chamberlain was CRUCIAL in the war's continuation during the war cabinet crisis, and had Chamberlain not existed it's possible Churchill may have been forced to resign and a peace treaty be brokered, because Churchill wasn't the leader of the party. And if that had occurred it's possible that the Nazis would have been victorious.
|
|
|
Post by Gassy on Jun 10, 2020 6:40:03 GMT
I agree. The highest ever was around a 2nd referendum which was something like 7m max! On a separate note: I see a huge crowd (could be thousands) of Coventry fans are gathering to celebrate in the town centre. No social distancing, no masks, no gloves & all drinking beers. Will they get the same reaction from so many about a 2nd wave? If Coventry fans do that then they are equally idiotic and selfish as the protestors or any other people that pre-arrange large gatherings at the moment. Fair enough Eric on your opinion. Although I'm more curious to see if they'll get the same reaction about the 2nd wave, rather than being called selfish.
|
|
|
Post by Gassy on Jun 10, 2020 6:42:25 GMT
I agree. The highest ever was around a 2nd referendum which was something like 7m max! On a separate note: I see a huge crowd (could be thousands) of Coventry fans are gathering to celebrate in the town centre. No social distancing, no masks, no gloves & all drinking beers. Will they get the same reaction from so many about a 2nd wave? Under normal circumstances they bloody well should do! Crowds are crowds- they aren’t allowed. Well, they *weren’t* allowed The moral argument has been well and truly lost by now. After the weekend gatherings are limited to no more than 20,000 it seems 🤷♂️ But the Coventry fans are chicken feed- the real issue is when Liverpool win the league and Leeds win the championship. Imagine that? Try telling their fans to go home and save lives after the police stood by and watched 137k break the rules. I couldn’t blame those fans for feeling aggrieved and kicking off if the Police start getting involved and issuing fines either. Lockdown is over, let’s face it- let people just do what they want now. We can only wait and see what the fallout is and if it’s severe, hold an inquest in the court of public opinion. Yeah I'm really curious what'll happen when Liverpool & Leeds win their respective leagues. I expect people out in at least the same numbers as the protests. Let's hope the country will be equally as scathing on Coventry fans, Liverpool etc about the 2nd wave. I get the feeling they wont - although maybe they will, any chance to blame Liverpool
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 10, 2020 7:02:36 GMT
If Coventry fans do that then they are equally idiotic and selfish as the protestors or any other people that pre-arrange large gatherings at the moment. Fair enough Eric on your opinion. Although I'm more curious to see if they'll get the same reaction about the 2nd wave, rather than being called selfish. I don’t think the media have been scathing enough about the protest in respect of disease spread. If I was in the media I wouldn’t say anything either as it would be damaging to my career. I’ve spoken to many friends and family and all have been critical and angry about the complete disregard to public safety during the protest. There have been plenty of newspaper headlines and tv pictures showing crowds on beaches etc (mostly white from the pictures I have seen) Attracting headlines like “Covidiots” and rightly labelled selfish morons. I don’t think there is any racial element to criticising poor etiquette in social distancing at these protests, any mass protest for any cause, by any demographic of people is not justified at the moment.
|
|