|
Post by blueridge on Feb 8, 2024 10:17:41 GMT
Agree. It’s like a vicious circle which means rebuilding every summer! What chance do we realistically have of signing Vale? Crama? Aguilera? The other 2 you probably won’t want anyway You can’t plan for long term growth if you have almost half your team returning to their clubs at seasons end Plan now to target our own players in the right positions and you can start to mould a team that will stick together Come on Matt, build us a young hungry Bristol Rovers FC Not a BRFC developing players for others FC!! UTG Without EA would we have ever got promoted and even recently what would the result have been at Exeter without BA's wonder goal? We have to get a happy mix, starting with 5 was madness on Tuesday, what message does that send to Sinclair and Brown etc when Vaughan just walked into the side? It's early days but is he really why better than Ryan Jones? Probably just the “message” they wanted to “send to Sinclair & Brown etc”
|
|
|
Post by chewbacca on Feb 8, 2024 10:44:54 GMT
Loanees are fine if they're;
a) Good players you'd usually not be able to sign. b) Cover in an area you are short. c) Potential future signings.
The fact Taylor started with five on Tuesday probably tells you more about the greatest squad ever put together in Bristol Rovers history ever than anything else can. While at Exeter loanees were used but not as much as they have by Rovers post-relegation.
Exeter City 2018/19 - 85 Appearances - 46 Game Season - 1.8 Per Game 2019/20 - 18 Appearances - 37 Game Season - 0.5 Per Game 2020/21 - 46 Appearances - 46 Game Season - 1 Per Game 2021/22 - 107 Appearances - 46 Game Season - 2.3 Per Game
Rovers 2021/22 - 121 Appearances - 46 Game Season - 2.6 Per Game 2022/23 - 132 Appearances - 46 Game Season - 2.9 Per Game 2023/24 - 99 Appearances - 30 Game Season - 3.3 Per Game
Having six players in the squad currently on loan is frankly insane and we should really be looking to sculpt a squad going forward that the manager can work with for 2-3 years that can be trimmed and added to when required.
|
|
|
Post by oldmarket65 on Feb 8, 2024 11:19:18 GMT
Some good posts on here and I’ve grown quite fond of Somerset’s posting, not that it matters what I think, but balanced, honest and emotive. All I would is, the manager is a proper no nonsense northerner, he cares and his sides seems to fight. Simply Tuesday night, he picked a bad side in terrible conditions against a side with a new manager bounce and players in, no different to Cogs going to the Kassam and beating Oxford whilst taking us our of relegation. I would to all, he’s inherited a squad which got its manager the sack, 69% at Burton and lost 4-1, the mind tends to forget stuff. Now think back to how Exeter played with a poor fan owned budget against us under our manager, was it 4-0 at half time at there place? Get your season tickets, give him a chance, I really think next season could one of those ones like Plymouth did the season before, top half, bang, adding to side, promotion push. As for Wilson, after that interview, I’m really wondering if he’s the sort to tell the physio, I hand better not risk it this week. That was a bloke in my mind, the afternoon before the game, thinking about the business he’s setting up when he retires soon or had a whisper Plymouth want him back as a coach next season knowing his calf can’t take it anymore! All that is fine roady as long as the board gives him a top 6-8 budget in the summer. All I'm saying is the club as raised the bar now by publicity stating we are a ' top budgeted ' club. I been put in my place by people like you backing this . Therefore : Taylor can be excused this season because he inherited Bartons team even though results have marginally improved. But fair is fair. If the club isn't in the top 8 by early November . What do we do ?. I just hope he's given the resources as promised.
|
|
|
Post by Topper Gas on Feb 8, 2024 12:03:30 GMT
Not sure one poster is suggesting we bumble along without a proper recruitment dept, the problem is we don't get a vote where the owners spend their money this summer nor how much they spend.
|
|
|
Post by Topper Gas on Feb 8, 2024 12:12:52 GMT
Loanees are fine if they're; a) Good players you'd usually not be able to sign. b) Cover in an area you are short. c) Potential future signings. The fact Taylor started with five on Tuesday probably tells you more about the greatest squad ever put together in Bristol Rovers history ever than anything else can. While at Exeter loanees were used but not as much as they have by Rovers post-relegation. Exeter City 2018/19 - 85 Appearances - 46 Game Season - 1.8 Per Game 2019/20 - 18 Appearances - 37 Game Season - 0.5 Per Game 2020/21 - 46 Appearances - 46 Game Season - 1 Per Game 2021/22 - 107 Appearances - 46 Game Season - 2.3 Per Game Rovers 2021/22 - 121 Appearances - 46 Game Season - 2.6 Per Game 2022/23 - 132 Appearances - 46 Game Season - 2.9 Per Game 2023/24 - 99 Appearances - 30 Game Season - 3.3 Per Game Having six players in the squad currently on loan is frankly insane and we should really be looking to sculpt a squad going forward that the manager can work with for 2-3 years that can be trimmed and added to when required. Exeter had a good academy probably producing players like Vaughan, ours seems to be non existent with Ward the only player to step up since Hoole and even he's not an outfield player. Loan players from Chelsea and the like seem to have taken the place of our own Academy. The club needs a massive overhaul but I'm not sure the owners will be prepared to do it, rather than look for short-term gains. Realistically what can MT plan when most managers depart within 2 years of being appointed. He's probably thinking he needs to produce a top 6 challenging squad in the summer or he'll be gone by this time next season.
|
|
|
Post by chewbacca on Feb 8, 2024 12:57:16 GMT
Loanees are fine if they're; a) Good players you'd usually not be able to sign. b) Cover in an area you are short. c) Potential future signings. The fact Taylor started with five on Tuesday probably tells you more about the greatest squad ever put together in Bristol Rovers history ever than anything else can. While at Exeter loanees were used but not as much as they have by Rovers post-relegation. Exeter City 2018/19 - 85 Appearances - 46 Game Season - 1.8 Per Game 2019/20 - 18 Appearances - 37 Game Season - 0.5 Per Game 2020/21 - 46 Appearances - 46 Game Season - 1 Per Game 2021/22 - 107 Appearances - 46 Game Season - 2.3 Per Game Rovers 2021/22 - 121 Appearances - 46 Game Season - 2.6 Per Game 2022/23 - 132 Appearances - 46 Game Season - 2.9 Per Game 2023/24 - 99 Appearances - 30 Game Season - 3.3 Per Game Having six players in the squad currently on loan is frankly insane and we should really be looking to sculpt a squad going forward that the manager can work with for 2-3 years that can be trimmed and added to when required. Exeter had a good academy probably producing players like Vaughan, ours seems to be non existent with Ward the only player to step up since Hoole and even he's not an outfield player. Loan players from Chelsea and the like seem to have taken the place of our own Academy. The club needs a massive overhaul but I'm not sure the owners will be prepared to do it, rather than look for short-term gains. Realistically what can MT plan when most managers depart within 2 years of being appointed. He's probably thinking he needs to produce a top 6 challenging squad in the summer or he'll be gone by this time next season. Much of it comes down to opportunities being given at the right time to let kids develop. Taylor's given Ward a platform to show what he can do, without that he could have been slipping down to NL for game time and never returning to the league. There's plenty of examples historically of young players at all sorts of clubs having the right manager at the right time. I'm hoping Taylor is open to developing our youngsters.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 9, 2024 6:21:57 GMT
Some good posts on here and I’ve grown quite fond of Somerset’s posting, not that it matters what I think, but balanced, honest and emotive. All I would is, the manager is a proper no nonsense northerner, he cares and his sides seems to fight. Simply Tuesday night, he picked a bad side in terrible conditions against a side with a new manager bounce and players in, no different to Cogs going to the Kassam and beating Oxford whilst taking us our of relegation. I would to all, he’s inherited a squad which got its manager the sack, 69% at Burton and lost 4-1, the mind tends to forget stuff. Now think back to how Exeter played with a poor fan owned budget against us under our manager, was it 4-0 at half time at there place? Get your season tickets, give him a chance, I really think next season could one of those ones like Plymouth did the season before, top half, bang, adding to side, promotion push. As for Wilson, after that interview, I’m really wondering if he’s the sort to tell the physio, I hand better not risk it this week. That was a bloke in my mind, the afternoon before the game, thinking about the business he’s setting up when he retires soon or had a whisper Plymouth want him back as a coach next season knowing his calf can’t take it anymore! All that is fine roady as long as the board gives him a top 6-8 budget in the summer. All I'm saying is the club as raised the bar now by publicity stating we are a ' top budgeted ' club. I been put in my place by people like you backing this . Therefore : Taylor can be excused this season because he inherited Bartons team even though results have marginally improved. But fair is fair. If the club isn't in the top 8 by early November . What do we do ?. I just hope he's given the resources as promised. For me the minimum I expect is a manager finishes relative to a league position to his budget and I also expect a good manager to over achieve. If he gets a top 8 budget again like Barton (we will know if this is true at the end of the season) then I expect 9,000 gates because we are sniffing around 6th place. If I see hope in the side but a gelling period happening in November and say we are even 16th, why would we sack him? We never sacked Trolls in the Feb when we lost at Boston before our promotion, we we were showing promise in the JPT. We never sacked DC for a terrible start in the National League or Barton in Div2……….November last year because a manager said he expected promotion this season, he said it publicly. It was also because the manager was having a public breakdown which has carried on into his personal life now with his outbursts and comments. We forget he was calling his players idiots in publicly and personally insulting opposition managers like Evans. Let’s get behind Taylor and give him time, the previous manager had two League 1 budgets building on a promotion Div2 side, he was failing terribly in the end, the form form January 1st 2022 was relegation form, something like 1.17 points a game over a calendar season.
|
|
|
Post by yattongas on Feb 9, 2024 12:14:52 GMT
I think a good manager can get a little more out of the players at his disposal pretty quickly. Yes , this isn’t Taylor’s team but he should quickly evaluate how good each player is , where they’ll be best deployed and what they are capable of. I’m not yet convinced Taylor has shown this yet. But … I’m of the opinion he should be given time and the chance to recruit the players that he wants . For the record I think he’ll come good but I’m one of life’s optimists especially when it comes to the Gas. 🙄😂
|
|
|
Post by DrFaustus on Feb 9, 2024 13:50:37 GMT
The manager publicly called out Brown and Sinclair the other day. Presumably neither will be part of any rebuild.
Had Barton done that, he would rightly have been severely criticised.
|
|
|
Post by oldmarket65 on Feb 9, 2024 14:06:20 GMT
The manager publicly called out Brown and Sinclair the other day. Presumably neither will be part of any rebuild. Had Barton done that, he would rightly have been severely criticised. And he publicity called out Luca Hoole on radio Bristol after the Blackpool game . Luca haven't kicked a ball since . And for the record Luca pre dates Barton and is the longest serving player at the club. It probably reflects the pressure Taylor is under as its been up and down and very little progress since Barton .
|
|
|
Post by percy on Feb 9, 2024 14:23:36 GMT
Good to hear (well read) Taylor talking about building a "more durable squad". Its what we all can see is needed. But also, not wanting a complete overhaul. As per the original post, still think we have a good core of 7/8 players we can build around plus a handful of youngsters that should be kept in the squad and tried properly in pre-season. UTG
|
|
|
Post by worrelsterlingalbion on Feb 9, 2024 14:31:47 GMT
The manager publicly called out Brown and Sinclair the other day. Presumably neither will be part of any rebuild. Had Barton done that, he would rightly have been severely criticised. I missed that, what did he say ?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 9, 2024 14:34:25 GMT
The manager publicly called out Brown and Sinclair the other day. Presumably neither will be part of any rebuild. Had Barton done that, he would rightly have been severely criticised. I must of missed this, can you send me the link, did he use words like “acted or is an idiot” and did he publicly say he can’t trust them like with Trev Clarke, if so I will take it back 👍 Also, while there, send over the link for calling Charlie Adam a “bald prick”. We got some desperate people on here trying to prove a point anyway. DC spoke publicly about Ellis, in a professional way, as does MT re his players. “If you had said to me at the end of last season Zain Westbrooke and Trevor Clarke were going to be in our starting XI on the opening day of the season, I would have said, ‘My god, we must have had a bad summer’.” He’s a good kid, he just can’t play the position how I want it played,” Barton said. “For me, he just doesn’t fill me with trust going forward. If I’m honest, I don’t trust him. I don’t think he’s the right component for us. We want to pass out, we want to play, and he’s not that type of full-back.” “I’ve been telling Trev all summer ‘I don’t trust you,” Barton continued. “You’re doing stuff in training, you’re not doing what I’m asking you to do, your retention of information I’m struggling with because how many times am I going to show you?’ “He’s not 17 or 19, he’s 24. So, at some point, the penny has got to drop. And after doing a year’s worth of work with him last year, I just got to the point where we need to pull up stumps here and just draw a line under it.
|
|
|
Post by oldmarket65 on Feb 9, 2024 14:37:21 GMT
This Saturday will be a good yardstick to make comparison to Barton. Under Barton our record was 4 4 5 = 16 points. Under Taylor it's 5 1 6 = 16 points but Taylor managed 1 less. So it's very straightforward.
A win plus +3 : A draw plus +1 : A defeat 0. It's the sort of comparison people will make from the board commentators managers players fans. Afterall data is flying around all the time !.
|
|
pirate
Forum Legend
Posts: 19,461
|
Post by pirate on Feb 9, 2024 14:52:19 GMT
Any progress on the appointment of a recruitment department and scouting network? Difficult to look forward to any rebuild without that in place, especially when you consider things got even worse for Taylor at his previous club after breaking their transfer record twice in one summer. What will be any different here?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 9, 2024 15:02:41 GMT
Any progress on the appointment of a recruitment department and scouting network? Difficult to look forward to any rebuild without that in place, especially when you consider things got even worse for Taylor at his previous club after breaking their transfer record twice in one summer. What will be any different here? 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 9, 2024 15:06:24 GMT
This Saturday will be a good yardstick to make comparison to Barton. Under Barton our record was 4 4 5 = 16 points. Under Taylor it's 5 1 6 = 16 points but Taylor managed 1 less. So it's very straightforward. A win plus +3 : A draw plus +1 : A defeat 0. It's the sort of comparison people will make from the board commentators managers players fans. Afterall data is flying around all the time !. I’m confused, am I missing something, why would anyone compare anything until Taylor has his own summer transfer window and proper go at it. I mean Hugo is always good at the stats, perhaps he can also stat us Barton taking over from Garner and Taylor taking over from Barton as well, we could divide it up and see a points per game total into the end of the season? Let’s do this shall we👍
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 9, 2024 15:10:27 GMT
It’s as if as well some want MT to fail, for the life of me I can’t see why anyone is getting excited about comparing stats to a bloke who averaged 1.17 in Div1, beat up with wife who dialled 999 in sheer desperation.
I think we are better just hammering the idiot and his mate who committed fraud 😂👍
|
|
|
Post by percy on Feb 9, 2024 15:22:11 GMT
Any progress on the appointment of a recruitment department and scouting network? Difficult to look forward to any rebuild without that in place, especially when you consider things got even worse for Taylor at his previous club after breaking their transfer record twice in one summer. What will be any different here? Hopefully it is raised (and answered satisfactorily) at the supporters club meet the owners in a few weeks. Anyone going? Please push this question!
|
|
|
Post by lavalamp on Feb 9, 2024 15:36:59 GMT
Unfortunately very unlikely, but Ian Atkins for DOF?
Last I heard he had joined the board of Northampton Town Supporters Trust (2021).
His knowledge of lower league football and players is immense.
I know people werent happy with the style of football he played, but just look at the players he signed for Rovers - Steve Elliot, Craig Hinton, Aaron Lescott, Craig Disley, Stuart Campbell, Richard Walker etc. - all able to play 30+ games a season and all very decent players.
Trollope and Lenny only really needed to add Steve Phillips and Rickie Lambert to the team to get us promoted (even although RL was allegedly signed by Geoff Dunford 🤷♂️).
|
|